Why ‘just war’ has given way to total war

On Remembrance Day, Pope Leo’s claim that just war is no longer possible rings true, as modern conflicts have replaced it with total war, where civilians become legitimate targets.
A general view of a World War II memorial. (Photo : Pexels)
A general view of a World War II memorial. (Photo : Pexels)

Subscribe to Newsletter

    Last week, on November 11, we marked Remembrance Day, (formerly Armistice Day), 108 years after the end of the First World War.

    We commemorated specifically those who died in the First World War (1914–1918), and, more generally, all those who have died in warfare subsequently: the Second World War (1939–1945), the Korean War (1950–1953), and hundreds of armed conflicts that have since threatened, or destroyed, nations’ sovereignty or independence, and taken countless civilian lives.

    Think Ukraine, Gaza, Sudan, Myanmar and the Democratic Republic of Congo, if you want contemporary examples.

    Pope Leo has suggested recently that it is no longer possible to wage what has been traditionally known as a “just war”.

    This is for two main reasons. The first is that in many contemporary conflicts, particularly those involving irregular forces, the distinction between soldiers and civilians is often difficult to maintain, and sometimes deliberately obscured. The second concerns the nature of modern warfare.

    Even with the development of precision weapons, aerial bombardment and artillery attacks, particularly in densely populated areas, carry a considerable risk of indiscriminate harm.

    Even when directed at military installations, such attacks can cause extensive damage to civilian buildings and infrastructure, and considerable loss of life. In just war terms, this raises serious questions of proportionality, particularly where the harm caused to civilians may be excessive in relation to the military advantage anticipated.

    So, instead of a just war, we have what might be called “total war”, in which civilians as well as the military come to be treated as legitimate targets of indiscriminate enemy attack. Civilian lives are no longer “collateral damage”.

    In just war theory their deaths could be “justified”, at least if they were inevitably associated with, and proportional to, the military objective achieved. But in total war they are part of the enemy resistance. Indeed, undermining civilian morale can become not just a secondary object of a sustained offensive, but perhaps an even more effective way of pursuing a war than engaging in armed conflict with the opposition’s military.

    In total war it is not just armies that pursue military objectives and implement defensive strategies. Whole nations, both military and civilians, are at war, and, as such, come to be regarded as legitimate targets of the enemy.

    Further, in total war, the distinction between military and civilian targets is increasingly disregarded. Civilian deaths resulting from aerial and artillery bombardment are treated not simply as collateral damage requiring justification, but as an accepted consequence of warfare, even when they might otherwise be judged disproportionate to the military objective achieved.

    They may be regrettable, but in the conduct of total war, the immunity of civilians, central to just war theory, is frequently disregarded. They are citizens of a nation that is engaged in a war and are at least secondary targets.

    “In total war it is not just armies that pursue military objectives and implement defensive strategies. Whole nations, both military and civilians, are at war, and, as such, come to be regarded as legitimate targets of the enemy.”

    Since the Second World War, when the German Luftwaffe indiscriminately bombed English cities, and in retaliation the English and Americans bombed Berlin and Hamburg, again indiscriminately, even though in each instance there was also some strategic military importance, it is total warfare rather than just war theory that has been operative.

    Lip service has been paid to the traditional theory by arguing that the loss of civilian life could be subsumed under the category “collateral damage”, i.e, that there was a sufficient proportion between the civilian lives lost and the military objective achieved, but most impartial commentators, with the benefit of hindsight, have seen such arguments as lacking substance, stretching the just war theory beyond its limits.

    And the dropping of the atomic bomb on Hiroshima and Nagasaki, although it possibly did save many lives by assisting to draw the war in the Pacific to its virtually immediate conclusion, could hardly claim to be anything else but a striking example of how far total war had overtaken just war.

    So we should reflect on where we have come to. Has the failure to distinguish between soldiers and civilians generally and employing weaponry that is indiscriminate in its operation committed us inevitably to the camp of total war?

    Could the multiple conditions that attended the articulation of the just war theory not be adapted to embrace a situation where, rather than army against army on the field of battle (perhaps as in the First World War), it is nation against nation, typically employing aerial bombardment and, recently, drone warfare, that has become the standard mode of conducting warfare?

    Most of us (perhaps not Mr Trump) are agreed that the prospect of war is terrifying. To this degree the importance of international diplomacy is absolute. What confronted St Augustine in the fifth century, when he articulated the definitive form of the just war theory,  as the Vandals were at the very gates of his city,  confronts us even more insistently today.

    November 11 is also the feast of St Martin of Tours, who was a soldier before he was a monk and a bishop. Let us hope that the prospect, and, in some cases, the actuality (think of the devastating loss of life and civilian suffering in Gaza, Sudan, Ukraine and Myanmar) of total war is so repulsive that we will find new ways to resolve disputes and to engineer peace.

    This column first appeared in Eureka Street and is republished by Global Catholic with permission.  

    Hope you loved reading this article. Global Catholic is powered by readers like you.

    We have no corporate owner or funding agencies. Our in-depth commentaries, features and conversations are not behind the paywall.

    We don’t carry advertisements as we want to offer a clutter-free reading experience.

    To sustain and grow Global Catholic, we need to raise US$250,000.

    Join the remarkable Global Catholic journey

    Share your comments

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    Pope Leo XIV welcomes Bob Dylan (third left) at the Vatican City alongside Fr. Antonio Spadaro (left). (Photo supplied)

    Bob Dylan and Pope Leo: two ‘Augustinians’

    Pope Leo XIV received Bob Dylan, an encounter rich with history, between a pope shaped by Augustine and the Bible, and a songwriter who has spoken Scripture for sixty years.
    Former US President Barack Obama (center) stands on stage with Democratic candidates Abdul El-Sayed (left) and Jocelyn Benson at a campaign rally in Detroit, Michigan. (Photo: Facebook/Democrats)

    An election and ‘humanating’

    Trump’s midterm defeat raises an uncomfortable question: did Americans repudiate Trumpism or just high fuel prices, and what would it mean to truly “humanate,” to live by Christ’s selfless love?
    A Christian man engaged in street ministry is seen holding a placard with a bible verse on God's love. (Photo: Pexels)

    Love: Most authentic force of evangelization

    The kerygma is God’s infinite love, and what truly attracts people to faith is not dogmatic orthodoxy but Christians who live that love toward the rejected and the suffering.
    Join the remarkable Global Catholic journey

    Join the remarkable Global Catholic journey

    Global Catholic is proud to be independent—editorially, politically, ideologically and financially.

    But independence comes at a cost. Without patron support, we depend entirely on readers and friends like you.

    To sustain and grow Global Catholic, we need to raise US$250,000.