Machines must never decide over life and death

As nations meet in Geneva, the Vatican leads calls to ban fully autonomous weapons, insisting that machines without conscience must never hold the power of life and death.
US Air Force team members assigned to the 2nd Civil Engineer Squadron operate Atom, a robot dog, at Barksdale Air Force Base, Los Angeles, Nov. 6, 2023. (Photo: US Department of War)
US Air Force team members assigned to the 2nd Civil Engineer Squadron operate Atom, a robot dog, at Barksdale Air Force Base, Los Angeles, Nov. 6, 2023. (Photo: US Department of War)

Subscribe to Newsletter

    Could a great hope finally become reality? The hope for binding rules governing the use of autonomous weapons!

    The path toward this goal is on the agenda of the Seventh Review Conference of the UN Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons (CCW) — a 1980 treaty restricting weapons deemed to cause excessive suffering or to strike indiscriminately — taking place at the Palais des Nations in Geneva from Nov. 16 to 20, 2026.

    Many of the 128 participating states hope that the conference will now launch negotiations on a binding international agreement.

    This is particularly true of those who have long called for bans on the use of AI-controlled weapons systems or, at the very least, their regulation.

    According to Reuters’ reports on Nov. 16, these include Germany and many European countries. And, of course, the Vatican. Pacifists are naturally calling for very comprehensive bans.

    Pope Leo does not go that far. In his encyclical Magnifica Humanitas, he criticized the use of the term “just war.” However, he upholds the Church’s teaching that, under strict conditions, people may use force to defend themselves and those who are defenseless against attack.

    The pope’s demand

    This position largely corresponds to the UN Charter. On Oct. 30, 2026, the Pope called for bans on lethal autonomous systems at the Vatican, as reported by the USCCB and multiple outlets.

    The connection between human dignity, personal responsibility, and legitimate defense is the foundation for this position. The central arguments that follow from this are as follows: Machines should not decide over the lives and deaths of human beings.

    At the highest level of so-called autonomy, the decision to kill people in war is irrevocably delegated to AI — possibly against the operator’s intentions. The victims are thus placed at the mercy of a machine that has neither a conscience nor an understanding of human dignity. This is a fundamental violation of human dignity.

    Calls for bans

    In addition to this fundamental position of the Pope, other arguments are important: The operator of such weapons also becomes a powerless instrument of the machine. This is because they have no possibility of intervening. This contradicts their autonomy. And responsibility cannot, as is sometimes claimed, be programmed into the systems as an “artificial morality.”

    Such supposed morality remains devoid of ethics because it lacks both a conscience and an understanding of the human person.

    Autonomous systems in which intervention is still possible, on the other hand, should be assessed differently, at least from my perspective as a Christian social ethicist. The same applies to autonomous air defense systems that target drones or similar machines and weapons. However, even here, rules are needed when human intervention is not possible.

    A Christian ethic should therefore allow for differentiated judgments. But one thing is clear: Fully autonomous weapons must be banned. The Vatican and many states agree on this.

    The Vatican could even serve as a moral authority and pioneer of such a coalition of values. It cannot be accused of pursuing military-strategic interests concealed behind an ethical facade.

    Considerable resistance to binding rules

    Following the preparations of recent years — including a Group of Governmental Experts report adopted Sept. 4, 2026, which offered the first consensus characterization of a lethal autonomous weapon system — the aim now is to pave the way for negotiations on a binding international protocol on autonomous weapons systems.

    A proposal for two years of negotiations on this matter is already on the table. However, there is considerable resistance. The United States and Israel object to binding commitments, while Russia considers such regulation fundamentally premature.

    China wants to allow such requirements only if they do not affect its own military power interests.

    Of course, moral arguments are sometimes put forward in this regard as well. For example, autonomous weapons know no desire for revenge and are therefore more humane in war than humans. AI precision would reduce collateral damage.

    Enforced rules are fundamentally hostile to innovation. Giving up certain weapons systems would make it more difficult to achieve success, for example, in the fight against terrorism and aggression.

    Potential threat scenarios

    Finally, bans and regulations are said to create a moral hazard: Those who do not abide by the rules would subsequently have the military and political upper hand. Surely that cannot be in the interest of the international community.

    Such legitimate arguments must be discussed seriously. But we must also be clear: The concerns of these countries are probably based less on social-ethical considerations than on self-interested strategic calculations.

    Especially in the face of concrete threats, strategic security interests can sometimes be understandable. However, they must be identified as such and must not be confused with fundamental ethical arguments. The different levels of discussion should be clearly identified and distinguished.

    This would mean holding separate panels in Geneva on ethics and on strategy, without mixing the two. Only afterward would the two be brought together in a plenary session, where the strategic arguments would be evaluated ethically. That would be a coherent program.

    What can we expect in Geneva?

    The question now is whether the international community has the political will to negotiate binding rules. Since the principle of consensus applies, even a single state can prevent such an initiative.

    And this probably makes it clear from the outset: The much-hoped-for launch of binding regulations on peace ethics will not happen in Geneva this time. The political will does not yet seem to be there.

    Nevertheless, the conference can take important steps in the right direction. No more, but no less. That is at least a realistic expectation. To achieve this, it must raise the awareness of all participants and the public about the pressing ethical and strategic questions and the answers already available.

    It must provide space for all sides through dialogue. At the same time, the positions of those blocking progress must be held up to the mirror in no uncertain terms, making clear what ultimately lies behind their objections.

    The goal is this: By the end of the conference, the international public should understand more clearly than ever that this is not merely a contest between ethical arguments, but a struggle between morality and military strategy.

    Such awareness alone is, of course, far less than hoped for. Yet it would be a first step toward making the different interests and arguments transparent in Geneva.

    A path toward a future protocol

    Building on this, political will for binding rules would have to develop. The concrete goal would ultimately be an international protocol with clear obligations and consequences.

    Following the negotiations, this should then be put to a vote. Ethical and strategic arguments for and against would have to be clearly distinguished and brought together in a final outcome. Such a protocol would not be adopted unanimously.

    Yet its signaling effect through transparency could be another milestone. It would awaken the international public, force strategic resistance to regulation to undergo ethical scrutiny, and thus prepare the hoped-for breakthrough.

    We do not need a meaningless consensus document.

    Perhaps, at the end of the process, a binding ban on fully autonomous lethal weapons will indeed be adopted — similar to the bans on cluster munitions and chemical and biological weapons. If not, then in the end an ethically acceptable outcome may only be achievable outside the principle of consensus.

    In other words, a binding protocol could be adopted by majority vote in the future. It would have to be enforced with UN authority and sanctions against signatories. International law would then still have to clarify how those states that did not approve the agreement and refuse to abide by it could at least be publicly denounced by the international community on moral grounds.

    Perhaps some expectations will be disappointed in Geneva. But the conference could take a decisive step toward making a great hope a reality: a world in which the decision over life and death is never fully delegated to machines. And the Vatican could provide crucial moral guidance in this process.

    This is a translated and edited version of the column that first appeared on Domradio.de and has been republished with permission.

    Hope you loved reading this article. Global Catholic is powered by readers like you.

    We have no corporate owner or funding agencies. Our in-depth commentaries, features and conversations are not behind the paywall.

    We don’t carry advertisements as we want to offer a clutter-free reading experience.

    To sustain and grow Global Catholic, we need to raise US$250,000.

    Join the remarkable Global Catholic journey

    Share your comments

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    Pope Leo XIV welcomes Bob Dylan (third left) at the Vatican City alongside Fr. Antonio Spadaro (left). (Photo supplied)

    Bob Dylan and Pope Leo: two ‘Augustinians’

    Pope Leo XIV received Bob Dylan, an encounter rich with history, between a pope shaped by Augustine and the Bible, and a songwriter who has spoken Scripture for sixty years.
    Former US President Barack Obama (center) stands on stage with Democratic candidates Abdul El-Sayed (left) and Jocelyn Benson at a campaign rally in Detroit, Michigan. (Photo: Facebook/Democrats)

    An election and ‘humanating’

    Trump’s midterm defeat raises an uncomfortable question: did Americans repudiate Trumpism or just high fuel prices, and what would it mean to truly “humanate,” to live by Christ’s selfless love?
    A Christian man engaged in street ministry is seen holding a placard with a bible verse on God's love. (Photo: Pexels)

    Love: Most authentic force of evangelization

    The kerygma is God’s infinite love, and what truly attracts people to faith is not dogmatic orthodoxy but Christians who live that love toward the rejected and the suffering.
    Join the remarkable Global Catholic journey

    Join the remarkable Global Catholic journey

    Global Catholic is proud to be independent—editorially, politically, ideologically and financially.

    But independence comes at a cost. Without patron support, we depend entirely on readers and friends like you.

    To sustain and grow Global Catholic, we need to raise US$250,000.