Why the political right weaponizes ‘family,’ and how the left should answer
The right’s political defense of “family” is less about moral virtue than a longing for order against upheaval, while the left should answer with an ethics of solidarity toward the weakest.
One common characteristic of right-wing and far-right political groups is that they defend a conservative, usually religious, view of the family and use this view as a political-religious argument against the left, accusing it of being against both family and God.
What is interesting is that sectors of the left, including the religious left, have difficulty responding to these accusations with arguments that would be persuasive to those who remain undecided in this controversy.
This is partly because most left-wing political arguments — which advocate reducing economic and social inequality and defending universal human rights (civil, social, political, and environmental) — were developed within the modern paradigm of secularization, which separates the private sphere of life from the public sphere. In other words, political debate would take place within the public sphere — the state and the market — while issues concerning family and religion would belong to the private sphere, separate from political discussion.
Family as a political battleground
Without entering into the debate over whether we still live in a world shaped by secularization or have entered a “post-secular world” — a term used by philosophers including Jürgen Habermas to describe societies where religion has not disappeared from public life as secularization theory once predicted — the fact is that not only religion but also the specific issue of “family” has become part of political discussions, especially during election periods.
In Brazil, Felipe Nunes — a political scientist and director of the polling firm Quaest — in his book Brasil no espelho (Brazil in the Mirror), which presents the findings of a survey of nearly 10,000 Brazilians across 340 municipalities, says that “in the Brazilian imagination, only devotion to family rivals religious devotion. […] For 96% of Brazilians, family is the most important thing in life.”
Thus, at a time when politics and elections are closely intertwined with opinion polls and the logic of marketing — offering consumers what they want — there is no way to separate the private sphere from the public one.
For this reason, sectors of the left have also been compelled to address this issue. Consider, for example, an article by Marcela Canero and Paulo Loiola on the Brasil de Fato website, titled “Faith, Family, and Homeland: The Debates the Left Cannot Shirk” (June 23, 2026).
They argue that “the progressive camp faces the challenge of communicating to the public that these have always been its priorities.” In presenting their case, they ask: “After all, what does defending the family mean if not fighting hunger, unemployment, debt, and poverty?
What does defending faith mean if not guaranteeing religious freedom and protecting coexistence among different beliefs?”
Progressive is not the same as left-wing
By bringing together the concept of “the progressive camp” and the defense of social rights, which is a left-wing concern, we risk creating confusion with important political consequences. Being progressive does not necessarily mean being left-wing or supporting the social rights of the poor.
There are progressives working in the fields of sexuality, ethnicity, and cultural pluralism who are not left-wing — in the classical sense of class struggle. In other words, some people who are progressive on issues of gender, sexuality, or ethnicity/race are right-wing and defend neoliberal values.
I personally knew a famous feminist who had no problem with neoliberalism. (As I recently wrote here at IHU, we must distinguish the conflict between conservatives and progressives from the conflict between the right and the left.)
It is true that the left’s priorities have always included the social rights of workers and the poor, but that does not mean that family has always been a priority for the left or for progressives.
After all, family is not, as the article seems to suggest, simply a group of individuals who come together to fight hunger, unemployment, and poverty. People from the middle class or the wealthy, who do not face these economic problems, also have family problems.
The family is a social institution grounded in universal human needs of biological origin: sexuality, reproduction, and daily subsistence.
Its members share a social space defined by relationships of kinship, marital union, and fatherhood and motherhood. In this sense, it is a microcosm of relations of production, reproduction, and distribution, with its own power structures and ideological and emotional components.
The sexual revolution’s unfinished argument
An important topic in the debate over the relationship between family, religion, and politics among conservative-right-wing and progressive-left-wing groups is the issue of sexuality.
The sexual revolution of the 1960s and 1970s was one expression of the modern utopian vision of a society, or social life, liberated from all forms of repression and oppression.
In other words, a life free from the repression of the family, the Church, and the state and, for the modern left, also from private property and the market system.
As progressives envision a utopia of a society free from the repression of the family and the Church or religion, it is understandable that they have not developed many arguments for engaging constructively with these issues.
Why family became a political flashpoint
And why has the issue of family become so important in politics over recent decades?
One hypothesis is that we are living through a period of major technological and social transformations (social media, AI, and so on), during which family and religious communities play a fundamental role.
As the economist Joseph Schumpeter — the Austrian-American economist (1883–1950) who popularized the phrase “creative destruction” to describe capitalism’s cycle of innovation and obsolescence — once said, capitalism is a system of “creative destruction”: “The fundamental impulse that sets and keeps the capitalist machine in motion comes from new consumer goods, new methods of production or transportation, new markets, and new forms of industrial organization that the capitalist creates.”
Constant creation also means the constant destruction of what loses out in market competition.
An excess of “creative destruction” makes everyday life impossible to live. This process needs to be counterbalanced by another force that provides a certain degree of stability.
For this reason, Peter Drucker — the Austrian-American management theorist (1909–2005), widely regarded as a founder of modern management studies — said that “society, community, and family are conservative institutions. They seek to maintain stability and avoid change, or at least slow it down” (Managing in a Time of Great Change).
Along the same lines, Manuel Castells — the Spanish sociologist known for his trilogy on the information age and network society — said that the technological revolution, the transformation of capitalism, the collapse of welfare-state projects, and new social movements such as feminism and environmentalism have generated a wide range of reactive movements.
These movements “dig their trenches of resistance in defense of God, the nation, ethnicity, the family, the region — in short, the fundamental categories of human existence throughout the millennia” (The Power of Identity).
Order, not virtue, is what’s really being defended
What lies behind the defense of “family” and God is not, fundamentally, a desire to restore traditional family and sexual moral values — if that were the case, the followers of Trump and Bolsonaro would not accept them, given their own less-than-“chaste” lives.
Rather, it is a desire for an order established by God that would allow his followers to defend themselves against chaos, that catastrophe of “creative destruction.” They are not seeking religious freedom but the order of “the one true God.”
For example, Bishop Edir Macedo — the Brazilian televangelist who founded the Universal Church of the Kingdom of God, one of the country’s largest Pentecostal denominations — writes in his book O perfil da família de Deus (The Profile of God’s Family) that the “origin of the family is in God” and that it was created for God’s eternal glory.
However, when humanity broke off its relationship with God and subjected itself to the devil, “the Earth, which should have been well governed by a perfect family, came to be governed by the children of rebellion, giving rise to chaos.”
For those unfamiliar with Pentecostal language, which is marked by biblical metaphors or simply religious symbols, the most important point here is the notion of chaos — of creative destruction — that characterizes our time.
Faced with this chaos, what people seek is the order of the lost “perfect” world. Such an order never actually existed, but it is present in humanity’s unconscious longing.
For this reason, Bishop Macedo offers the meaning and direction of his spiritual and political warfare: “Satan’s greatest target throughout the world has been the family.
This is because, by destroying one home, he will destroy other homes through those initial family members, increasingly obstructing the divine purpose of establishing His Kingdom here on Earth.”
A different starting point: solidarity over order
This helps us understand the language used and the importance attributed to family in the relationship between politics and religious groups.
It is not enough to criticize the patriarchal and sexist model of the family; we must also offer an alternative vision of family, because without a family, children and young people will have great difficulty growing into healthy adults.
Pope Leo XIV, during his November 2026 apostolic visit to Argentina — part of his first Latin American trip as pontiff, which also took him to Uruguay and Peru — offers us a clue as to another way of discussing family: “The family, the fundamental cell of society, occupies an essential place here. Within it, each person learns to discover that their life is connected to the lives of others and that they are also responsible for them.
At home, we learn to care for the weakest, to forgive, to share, and to stand alongside those who need help; it is also there that many men and women receive the first seeds of faith.” The focus must shift from “order” to the ethics of solidarity with the weakest.
This is a translated and edited version of the column that first appeared on Instituto Humanitas Unisinos and has been republished with permission.
Hope you loved reading this article. Global Catholic is powered by readers like you.
We have no corporate owner or funding agencies. Our in-depth commentaries, features and conversations are not behind the paywall.
We don’t carry advertisements as we want to offer a clutter-free reading experience.
To sustain and grow Global Catholic, we need to raise US$250,000.
Having retraced Francis’s legacy from Uruguay to Argentina, Leo casts his South American journey as traveling in reverse the road his predecessor once walked.
The midterm rebuke to Trumpism offers the Church a chance to free itself from ideological captivity, from the partisan entanglements that distorted its moral and social teaching.
Pope Leo XIV received Bob Dylan, an encounter rich with history, between a pope shaped by Augustine and the Bible, and a songwriter who has spoken Scripture for sixty years.
Trump’s midterm defeat raises an uncomfortable question: did Americans repudiate Trumpism or just high fuel prices, and what would it mean to truly “humanate,” to live by Christ’s selfless love?
The kerygma is God’s infinite love, and what truly attracts people to faith is not dogmatic orthodoxy but Christians who live that love toward the rejected and the suffering.
As tech companies turn to religion for moral guidance, the real question is not whether machines can gain a conscience, but whether humanity has conscience enough to govern artificial intelligence.
Why the political right weaponizes ‘family,’ and how the left should answer
Google Search
Subscribe to Newsletter
One common characteristic of right-wing and far-right political groups is that they defend a conservative, usually religious, view of the family and use this view as a political-religious argument against the left, accusing it of being against both family and God.
What is interesting is that sectors of the left, including the religious left, have difficulty responding to these accusations with arguments that would be persuasive to those who remain undecided in this controversy.
This is partly because most left-wing political arguments — which advocate reducing economic and social inequality and defending universal human rights (civil, social, political, and environmental) — were developed within the modern paradigm of secularization, which separates the private sphere of life from the public sphere. In other words, political debate would take place within the public sphere — the state and the market — while issues concerning family and religion would belong to the private sphere, separate from political discussion.
Family as a political battleground
Without entering into the debate over whether we still live in a world shaped by secularization or have entered a “post-secular world” — a term used by philosophers including Jürgen Habermas to describe societies where religion has not disappeared from public life as secularization theory once predicted — the fact is that not only religion but also the specific issue of “family” has become part of political discussions, especially during election periods.
In Brazil, Felipe Nunes — a political scientist and director of the polling firm Quaest — in his book Brasil no espelho (Brazil in the Mirror), which presents the findings of a survey of nearly 10,000 Brazilians across 340 municipalities, says that “in the Brazilian imagination, only devotion to family rivals religious devotion. […] For 96% of Brazilians, family is the most important thing in life.”
Thus, at a time when politics and elections are closely intertwined with opinion polls and the logic of marketing — offering consumers what they want — there is no way to separate the private sphere from the public one.
For this reason, sectors of the left have also been compelled to address this issue. Consider, for example, an article by Marcela Canero and Paulo Loiola on the Brasil de Fato website, titled “Faith, Family, and Homeland: The Debates the Left Cannot Shirk” (June 23, 2026).
They argue that “the progressive camp faces the challenge of communicating to the public that these have always been its priorities.” In presenting their case, they ask: “After all, what does defending the family mean if not fighting hunger, unemployment, debt, and poverty?
What does defending faith mean if not guaranteeing religious freedom and protecting coexistence among different beliefs?”
Progressive is not the same as left-wing
By bringing together the concept of “the progressive camp” and the defense of social rights, which is a left-wing concern, we risk creating confusion with important political consequences. Being progressive does not necessarily mean being left-wing or supporting the social rights of the poor.
There are progressives working in the fields of sexuality, ethnicity, and cultural pluralism who are not left-wing — in the classical sense of class struggle. In other words, some people who are progressive on issues of gender, sexuality, or ethnicity/race are right-wing and defend neoliberal values.
I personally knew a famous feminist who had no problem with neoliberalism. (As I recently wrote here at IHU, we must distinguish the conflict between conservatives and progressives from the conflict between the right and the left.)
It is true that the left’s priorities have always included the social rights of workers and the poor, but that does not mean that family has always been a priority for the left or for progressives.
After all, family is not, as the article seems to suggest, simply a group of individuals who come together to fight hunger, unemployment, and poverty. People from the middle class or the wealthy, who do not face these economic problems, also have family problems.
The family is a social institution grounded in universal human needs of biological origin: sexuality, reproduction, and daily subsistence.
Its members share a social space defined by relationships of kinship, marital union, and fatherhood and motherhood. In this sense, it is a microcosm of relations of production, reproduction, and distribution, with its own power structures and ideological and emotional components.
The sexual revolution’s unfinished argument
An important topic in the debate over the relationship between family, religion, and politics among conservative-right-wing and progressive-left-wing groups is the issue of sexuality.
The sexual revolution of the 1960s and 1970s was one expression of the modern utopian vision of a society, or social life, liberated from all forms of repression and oppression.
In other words, a life free from the repression of the family, the Church, and the state and, for the modern left, also from private property and the market system.
As progressives envision a utopia of a society free from the repression of the family and the Church or religion, it is understandable that they have not developed many arguments for engaging constructively with these issues.
Why family became a political flashpoint
And why has the issue of family become so important in politics over recent decades?
One hypothesis is that we are living through a period of major technological and social transformations (social media, AI, and so on), during which family and religious communities play a fundamental role.
As the economist Joseph Schumpeter — the Austrian-American economist (1883–1950) who popularized the phrase “creative destruction” to describe capitalism’s cycle of innovation and obsolescence — once said, capitalism is a system of “creative destruction”: “The fundamental impulse that sets and keeps the capitalist machine in motion comes from new consumer goods, new methods of production or transportation, new markets, and new forms of industrial organization that the capitalist creates.”
Constant creation also means the constant destruction of what loses out in market competition.
An excess of “creative destruction” makes everyday life impossible to live. This process needs to be counterbalanced by another force that provides a certain degree of stability.
For this reason, Peter Drucker — the Austrian-American management theorist (1909–2005), widely regarded as a founder of modern management studies — said that “society, community, and family are conservative institutions. They seek to maintain stability and avoid change, or at least slow it down” (Managing in a Time of Great Change).
Along the same lines, Manuel Castells — the Spanish sociologist known for his trilogy on the information age and network society — said that the technological revolution, the transformation of capitalism, the collapse of welfare-state projects, and new social movements such as feminism and environmentalism have generated a wide range of reactive movements.
These movements “dig their trenches of resistance in defense of God, the nation, ethnicity, the family, the region — in short, the fundamental categories of human existence throughout the millennia” (The Power of Identity).
Order, not virtue, is what’s really being defended
What lies behind the defense of “family” and God is not, fundamentally, a desire to restore traditional family and sexual moral values — if that were the case, the followers of Trump and Bolsonaro would not accept them, given their own less-than-“chaste” lives.
Rather, it is a desire for an order established by God that would allow his followers to defend themselves against chaos, that catastrophe of “creative destruction.” They are not seeking religious freedom but the order of “the one true God.”
For example, Bishop Edir Macedo — the Brazilian televangelist who founded the Universal Church of the Kingdom of God, one of the country’s largest Pentecostal denominations — writes in his book O perfil da família de Deus (The Profile of God’s Family) that the “origin of the family is in God” and that it was created for God’s eternal glory.
However, when humanity broke off its relationship with God and subjected itself to the devil, “the Earth, which should have been well governed by a perfect family, came to be governed by the children of rebellion, giving rise to chaos.”
For those unfamiliar with Pentecostal language, which is marked by biblical metaphors or simply religious symbols, the most important point here is the notion of chaos — of creative destruction — that characterizes our time.
Faced with this chaos, what people seek is the order of the lost “perfect” world. Such an order never actually existed, but it is present in humanity’s unconscious longing.
For this reason, Bishop Macedo offers the meaning and direction of his spiritual and political warfare: “Satan’s greatest target throughout the world has been the family.
This is because, by destroying one home, he will destroy other homes through those initial family members, increasingly obstructing the divine purpose of establishing His Kingdom here on Earth.”
A different starting point: solidarity over order
This helps us understand the language used and the importance attributed to family in the relationship between politics and religious groups.
It is not enough to criticize the patriarchal and sexist model of the family; we must also offer an alternative vision of family, because without a family, children and young people will have great difficulty growing into healthy adults.
Pope Leo XIV, during his November 2026 apostolic visit to Argentina — part of his first Latin American trip as pontiff, which also took him to Uruguay and Peru — offers us a clue as to another way of discussing family: “The family, the fundamental cell of society, occupies an essential place here. Within it, each person learns to discover that their life is connected to the lives of others and that they are also responsible for them.
At home, we learn to care for the weakest, to forgive, to share, and to stand alongside those who need help; it is also there that many men and women receive the first seeds of faith.” The focus must shift from “order” to the ethics of solidarity with the weakest.
This is a translated and edited version of the column that first appeared on Instituto Humanitas Unisinos and has been republished with permission.
Hope you loved reading this article. Global Catholic is powered by readers like you.
We have no corporate owner or funding agencies. Our in-depth commentaries, features and conversations are not behind the paywall.
We don’t carry advertisements as we want to offer a clutter-free reading experience.
To sustain and grow Global Catholic, we need to raise US$250,000.
Join the remarkable Global Catholic journey
VATICAN DIARY
Leo carries Francis’ legacy through Latin America
SIGNS OF THE TIMES
US midterms: A liberating invitation for the US Church
WAYPOINTS
Bob Dylan and Pope Leo: two ‘Augustinians’
GRIMMGRAM
An election and ‘humanating’
LIGHTS AND SHADOWS
Love: Most authentic force of evangelization
MORALITY MATTERS
Can Artificial Intelligence have a conscience?
Latest
Why the political right weaponizes ‘family,’ and how the left should answer
‘I lived with a saint’: Carlo Acutis’ mother remembers her son
The age of deference is over, even in the Church
‘My Mass’: two words that reveal a deeper problem
The Catholic Church cannot stand neutral in the face of injustice
Council of Crete at 10: The unfinished work of Christian unity
Trending
Theology for a Synodal Church: Vatican II’s unfinished legacy
Can Artificial Intelligence have a conscience?
Leo carries Francis’ legacy through Latin America
Neither flight, nor flag: Benedict, Dominic and the Council
Mega Anthropic IPO: Should Christians invest?
Why the German Church still wrestles with its liturgical translations from Latin
Why a Eucharistic Revival didn’t increase belief among American Catholics
America rejected Trump, yet he governs on: what happens now?
Should the Church still speak of ‘heresy’?
From spy chief to Vatican envoy: Germany’s ambassador on Pope Leo