New Phyllis Zagano book argues women deacons debate is not settled
Phyllis Zagano’s book offers a precise, well-documented history of the debate over restoring women to the diaconate, arguing the question remains theologically open while framing it as a matter of justice, dignity and belonging.
Title:The Vatican and Women Deacons Author: Phyllis Zagano Publisher: Orbis Books Publication date: May 20, 2026 Format: Paperback Pages: 224 Price: US$20
I’ve long thought there’ll be awards in heaven for persistence and precision in scholarship, as well as for scholars who demonstrate that the university is the place where the church does her thinking. Prominent in that lineup, I feel certain, will be Phyllis Zagano.
Take a look at her latest book, The Vatican and Women Deacons, and see if you agree.
Please do not skip the Acknowledgments at the beginning, where you will find a story, a passion, and a scholarly trail. In addition to everything else, I admire her precision in punctuation, including commas and semicolons, which matches the care she gives to careful exposition.
She points out that in 1960, Jean Cardinal Daniélou, a French Jesuit and well-respected patrologist, theologian, and historian, concluded that there are “three possible ways of ordering the ministry of women: lay, clerical, religious. It can be said that all three are equally traditional.”
Those who say Roma locuta, causa finita have not been paying attention. They may also have missed Cardinal Robert Prevost at a 2023 synod press conference, where he said that while the church had definitively ruled against women priests, the question of women deacons was under discussion.
One of Zagano’s attributes is presenting material, historical lessons, and ongoing questions in a way that invites thoughtful consideration, deeper study, and more fervent prayer. Very significantly, she models a willingness to listen.
She also helps the reader recognize that the issue is to restore women to the diaconate as in the early Church. Whether those deacons were ever ordained or not remains a matter of debate.
Her careful scholarship informs those on both sides of the question that the issue is a matter of justice. Again and again, it is made clear that what comes from the Holy Spirit cannot be stopped, echoing the Acts of the Apostles, “For if this endeavor or this activity is of human origin, it will destroy itself” (5:38).
Those entering the discussion do well to remember that the diaconate as a permanent vocation was restored by Pope Paul VI in 1967, which in Roman chronology means just yesterday.
Zagano highlights the commission’s work on the role of women in society and in the church, 1973 through 1975, and then moves on to examine the work of the International Theological Commission, 1969 through 1976. Many readers may be surprised to see how rich the conversation has been, both in preparation for and since the Second Vatican Council.
She writes, “the history of women in the diaconate was well known, and the fact of their sacramental ordinations was routinely challenged. Concurrently, the belief that ordination as deacons would imply the possibility of ordination as priest continued to confuse the issue.”
She then details the academic debate from 1971 to 1982, noting that objections to restoring women to the diaconate are raised by newcomers to the discussion, “who too often ignore even the fact that the question has not been magisterially settled.”
She points out that John Paul II, Benedict XVI, and Francis have restated the policy that women cannot be ordained as priests, though “none has presented any doctrine that eliminates the restoration of women to the ordained diaconate.”
When Pope Francis called for an official commission to study the question of women in the diaconate, Zagano was among the twelve appointed. The commission first met in 2016, and at the final luncheon in June 2018 at the Domus Sanctae Marthae guesthouse, Pope Francis approached their table, thanked them informally, and asked who the first deaconess would be. The commissioners pointed to Zagano.
The book’s Appendix II, “For A Synodal Church Communion, Participation, Mission Final Document”, clearly states that men and women, both baptized, have equal dignity as members of the people of God.
Women, however, encounter obstacles in obtaining a full recognition of their charisms, vocation and place in the Church’s life. “This is to the detriment of serving the Church’s shared mission.” Further, “the question of women’s access to diaconal ministry remains open.”
It is important to approach Zagano’s work with a clear expectation and an understanding that one will find a thoughtful curation of discussions, proposals, ideas, ideals, and historical references that demonstrate a long, well-considered record of a very serious matter in the life of the church.
While different cultures may approach the issue with different concerns, the question of how women can and will and should serve in the church cannot be addressed by avoiding the question or solved by agreeing to disagree.
This is a matter of human dignity, equality, and difference, of belonging fully to Christ as members of the body of which he is the head. The outcome of this debate is one that the future church, in a not-so-distant tomorrow, will certainly affirm with the same unanimity with which it affirms the two natures of Christ in the Creed and the Real Presence of Christ in the Eucharist.
Thoughtful scholarship, untiring determination, and a great love for the church shine forth in this book and in the faithful perseverance of Phyllis Zagano, who encourages all people of good will to continue the conversation.
Hope you loved reading this article. Global Catholic is powered by readers like you.
We have no corporate owner or funding agencies. Our in-depth commentaries, features and conversations are not behind the paywall.
We don’t carry advertisements as we want to offer a clutter-free reading experience.
To sustain and grow Global Catholic, we need to raise US$250,000.
Having retraced Francis’s legacy from Uruguay to Argentina, Leo casts his South American journey as traveling in reverse the road his predecessor once walked.
The midterm rebuke to Trumpism offers the Church a chance to free itself from ideological captivity, from the partisan entanglements that distorted its moral and social teaching.
Pope Leo XIV received Bob Dylan, an encounter rich with history, between a pope shaped by Augustine and the Bible, and a songwriter who has spoken Scripture for sixty years.
Trump’s midterm defeat raises an uncomfortable question: did Americans repudiate Trumpism or just high fuel prices, and what would it mean to truly “humanate,” to live by Christ’s selfless love?
The kerygma is God’s infinite love, and what truly attracts people to faith is not dogmatic orthodoxy but Christians who live that love toward the rejected and the suffering.
As tech companies turn to religion for moral guidance, the real question is not whether machines can gain a conscience, but whether humanity has conscience enough to govern artificial intelligence.
New Phyllis Zagano book argues women deacons debate is not settled
Google Search
Subscribe to Newsletter
Title: The Vatican and Women Deacons
Author: Phyllis Zagano
Publisher: Orbis Books
Publication date: May 20, 2026
Format: Paperback
Pages: 224
Price: US$20
I’ve long thought there’ll be awards in heaven for persistence and precision in scholarship, as well as for scholars who demonstrate that the university is the place where the church does her thinking. Prominent in that lineup, I feel certain, will be Phyllis Zagano.
Take a look at her latest book, The Vatican and Women Deacons, and see if you agree.
Please do not skip the Acknowledgments at the beginning, where you will find a story, a passion, and a scholarly trail. In addition to everything else, I admire her precision in punctuation, including commas and semicolons, which matches the care she gives to careful exposition.
She points out that in 1960, Jean Cardinal Daniélou, a French Jesuit and well-respected patrologist, theologian, and historian, concluded that there are “three possible ways of ordering the ministry of women: lay, clerical, religious. It can be said that all three are equally traditional.”
Those who say Roma locuta, causa finita have not been paying attention. They may also have missed Cardinal Robert Prevost at a 2023 synod press conference, where he said that while the church had definitively ruled against women priests, the question of women deacons was under discussion.
One of Zagano’s attributes is presenting material, historical lessons, and ongoing questions in a way that invites thoughtful consideration, deeper study, and more fervent prayer. Very significantly, she models a willingness to listen.
She also helps the reader recognize that the issue is to restore women to the diaconate as in the early Church. Whether those deacons were ever ordained or not remains a matter of debate.
Her careful scholarship informs those on both sides of the question that the issue is a matter of justice. Again and again, it is made clear that what comes from the Holy Spirit cannot be stopped, echoing the Acts of the Apostles, “For if this endeavor or this activity is of human origin, it will destroy itself” (5:38).
Those entering the discussion do well to remember that the diaconate as a permanent vocation was restored by Pope Paul VI in 1967, which in Roman chronology means just yesterday.
Zagano highlights the commission’s work on the role of women in society and in the church, 1973 through 1975, and then moves on to examine the work of the International Theological Commission, 1969 through 1976. Many readers may be surprised to see how rich the conversation has been, both in preparation for and since the Second Vatican Council.
She writes, “the history of women in the diaconate was well known, and the fact of their sacramental ordinations was routinely challenged. Concurrently, the belief that ordination as deacons would imply the possibility of ordination as priest continued to confuse the issue.”
She then details the academic debate from 1971 to 1982, noting that objections to restoring women to the diaconate are raised by newcomers to the discussion, “who too often ignore even the fact that the question has not been magisterially settled.”
She points out that John Paul II, Benedict XVI, and Francis have restated the policy that women cannot be ordained as priests, though “none has presented any doctrine that eliminates the restoration of women to the ordained diaconate.”
When Pope Francis called for an official commission to study the question of women in the diaconate, Zagano was among the twelve appointed. The commission first met in 2016, and at the final luncheon in June 2018 at the Domus Sanctae Marthae guesthouse, Pope Francis approached their table, thanked them informally, and asked who the first deaconess would be. The commissioners pointed to Zagano.
The book’s Appendix II, “For A Synodal Church Communion, Participation, Mission Final Document”, clearly states that men and women, both baptized, have equal dignity as members of the people of God.
Women, however, encounter obstacles in obtaining a full recognition of their charisms, vocation and place in the Church’s life. “This is to the detriment of serving the Church’s shared mission.” Further, “the question of women’s access to diaconal ministry remains open.”
It is important to approach Zagano’s work with a clear expectation and an understanding that one will find a thoughtful curation of discussions, proposals, ideas, ideals, and historical references that demonstrate a long, well-considered record of a very serious matter in the life of the church.
While different cultures may approach the issue with different concerns, the question of how women can and will and should serve in the church cannot be addressed by avoiding the question or solved by agreeing to disagree.
This is a matter of human dignity, equality, and difference, of belonging fully to Christ as members of the body of which he is the head. The outcome of this debate is one that the future church, in a not-so-distant tomorrow, will certainly affirm with the same unanimity with which it affirms the two natures of Christ in the Creed and the Real Presence of Christ in the Eucharist.
Thoughtful scholarship, untiring determination, and a great love for the church shine forth in this book and in the faithful perseverance of Phyllis Zagano, who encourages all people of good will to continue the conversation.
Hope you loved reading this article. Global Catholic is powered by readers like you.
We have no corporate owner or funding agencies. Our in-depth commentaries, features and conversations are not behind the paywall.
We don’t carry advertisements as we want to offer a clutter-free reading experience.
To sustain and grow Global Catholic, we need to raise US$250,000.
Join the remarkable Global Catholic journey
VATICAN DIARY
Leo carries Francis’ legacy through Latin America
SIGNS OF THE TIMES
US midterms: A liberating invitation for the US Church
WAYPOINTS
Bob Dylan and Pope Leo: two ‘Augustinians’
GRIMMGRAM
An election and ‘humanating’
LIGHTS AND SHADOWS
Love: Most authentic force of evangelization
MORALITY MATTERS
Can Artificial Intelligence have a conscience?
Latest
Can Artificial Intelligence have a conscience?
Jesus’ prophecies are a warning, not a verdict
Meet the Catholic nuns walking miles to serve Vietnam’s forgotten ethnic villagers
From medieval carvings to Nostra Aetate: confronting Christian antisemitism
America rejected Trump, yet he governs on: what happens now?
Mega Anthropic IPO: Should Christians invest?
Trending
US midterms: A liberating invitation for the US Church
Theology for a Synodal Church: Vatican II’s unfinished legacy
Leo carries Francis’ legacy through Latin America
Love: Most authentic force of evangelization
Can Artificial Intelligence have a conscience?
Meet the Kenyan sister breaking the silence on abuse of nuns
Mega Anthropic IPO: Should Christians invest?
Homophobia and misogyny in the Church share one root, argues Spanish theologian
From spy chief to Vatican envoy: Germany’s ambassador on Pope Leo
America rejected Trump, yet he governs on: what happens now?