This column is the first part of a three-part series. Click here to read part two and part three.
Gloria Steinem died on Sept. 2 at age 92. Chief among her accomplishments, it seems to me, was highlighting what may be an unbridgeable divide in American life.
She wrote and spoke of having had an abortion at 22, in 1957, when it was illegal almost everywhere except the Soviet bloc and parts of East Asia.
She somehow found a doctor; she dedicated her 2015 memoir to him, reporting that he told her, “You must promise me two things. First, you will not tell anyone my name. Second, you will do what you want to do with your life.”
“Do what you want” is, I think, a dangerous theme. I might be a minority voice.
Writing in The New York Times (Sept. 3), Jill Filipovic lauds Steinem triumphantly, asserting that she did “more than anyone could have possibly imagined with her life.” Among her biggest accomplishments was enabling millions of other women to do what they wanted with their lives.
“At the core of that work was reproductive freedom, as she called it: the right to have sex for pleasure without shame and to say no without grave consequence, to use contraception to prevent unintended pregnancies, to have access to safe and legal abortion, to have children by choice in safety and with support. She, and the second-wave feminist movement of which she was a part, succeeded in many of those aims. Premarital sex has been largely stripped of its stigma.”
This is as stark a contrast as possible to the Catholic views of the purposes of sex, and of marriage as a sacrament in which husband and wife promise love and faithfulness until death, with a willingness to procreate, all in imitation of and cooperation with the perfecting love of God.
Different couples or cultures may interpret the marriage vows differently, and not every individual understanding may align with the higher aspirations the vows suggest.
However, there is no conceivable sacramental interpretation of vows, marriage, sex, or Christian vocation, or of conforming one’s heart to the heart of Jesus, that can include “Do what you want,” because the human condition often prompts us to want selfishly, in ways that harm ourselves and others.
Imagine the newly pregnant Mary rushing off to announce the surprising, impending arrival of the Messiah to her cousin Elizabeth, who is herself pregnant with John the Baptist.
In the Visitation, we see illustrated the contrast between joyful cooperation in an earth-shaking event and steadfastly maintaining one’s own agenda in the pursuit of individual goals.
Both women were cooperating with a mission and a promise with implications reaching far beyond their immediate, familial sphere.
What are the chances that one said to the other, “Do what you want with your life”? They could be, however, the first poster children for the ‘Sisterhood Is Powerful’ movement.
Thinking about doing what you want ought to come with a how-to guide for forming conscience. If that is already an essential part of pursuing reproductive freedom, I may have missed that instruction.
❝
We are in a place where there is a fundamental and perhaps irreconcilable difference between a traditional, Christian understanding of sex, marriage, and morals, and what is preferred, promoted, and legally enjoyed by others.
I heard a radio interview with one of Steinem’s early collaborators on Ms. Magazine, who suggested that abortion freedom is a homage to motherhood because access to abortion ensures that only those who choose motherhood become mothers.
Then I imagined being back in Father Stromberg’s logic class in St. Paul in September 1968, watching him show how logical fallacies work. And how they don’t.
I intend to consult a logician soon, but I wonder whether this could be the fallacy of equivocation. It might bring to mind Heinrich Himmler’s famous speech, in which he praised SS soldiers for their bravery in killing women and children, despite having families, and thus the executions caused them pain, too.
Let’s review:
- “At the core of that work was reproductive freedom, as she called it: the right to have sex for pleasure without shame and to say no without grave consequence.” She would not add “in the context of marriage.” Significant difference in approach.
- “[T]o use contraception to prevent unintended pregnancies.” There is at least a possibility of this being, as we used to say, morally objectionable in part.
- “[T]o have access to safe and legal abortion.” That’s the law. It is the woman’s choice alone. Though the fetus is entirely dependent on the mother, the unasked question is whether or not an aborted fetus is a victim.
- “[T]o have children by choice in safety and with support.” Agree.
- “She, and the second-wave feminist movement of which she was a part, succeeded in many of those aims.” Doing what you want with your life = getting what you want? Not always.
- “Premarital sex has been largely stripped of its stigma.” I guess. And extramarital sex, too. Is that good?
It is very interesting that Steinem saw surrogacy as exploitation of women, but unbridled sexual activity as liberation. I see a disconnect. What about doing what you want with your life? And your womb?
Here, I think, is an issue: we are in a place where there is a fundamental and perhaps irreconcilable difference between a traditional, Christian understanding of sex, marriage, and morals, and what is preferred, promoted, and legally enjoyed by others. Is it a fifty-fifty division? I don’t know.
Gaudium et Spes insists that peace is not merely the absence of war but the ongoing work of justice (GS 78).
Justice does not always allow us to do whatever we want. We need to determine whether justice permits such radical diversity in life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness. If so, how? If not, then what?
I am not seeking to shame or ridicule those who approach these matters in ways I don’t share or even really understand. My question is not religious. Instead, I am wondering how we will persevere as a society with such vast differences. And I wonder whether the challenge to do what you want comes with a question: At what cost?
One thing we have seen over the past 50 years is that voting one way or another has not seemed to bridge the societal chasm that divides those who seek unfettered reproductive freedom from those who continue to oppose abortion on demand.
Can our society either endure or prosper with such a sharp divergence on so many matters about what it means to be human and how to be human, and what goodness and truth look like?
That question is, I think, of utmost importance. And very frightening. And deeply alarming.
This column is the first part of a three-part series. Click here to read part two.
















1 Comment
John
September 17, 2026Well written