Here’s something I hadn’t considered in my cantankerous reflections on the sorry plight affecting so many of our Catholic colleges and universities: defensive administrators, asked to explain what makes their institutions Catholic, might turn to AI to craft their response. Lesson learned: There is no problem we cannot make worse.
I don’t have evidence that this particular use of AI is widespread. But the practice would be, I think, a hateful strategy for a number of reasons:
- It does what it deplores among students.
- It gives the impression that careful consideration has been given a matter they’d rather ignore when they’ve done no more than feed a query and a typed prompt into a box.
- They have demonstrated no meaningful commitment to pursuing matters of the soul and heart.
- It gives the unmistakable impression that they don’t want to be bothered.
- It’s lazy.
- It is condescending.
- It’s off-putting.
- It is an affront to human dignity.
- They bring shame to the academy.
- They have abandoned what remains of their foundational mission.
I read what appeared to be a long, thoughtful response to my rumination, privately delivered (not in the comments box), considered it a bit, and later asked a particularly astute colleague to review it.
His response floored me.
He first asked me, “What do you make of the response?”
“I thought that it was gracious and not defensive. But that she thinks all is well. You?”
“It had an AI feel to it.”
So, I pasted it into the box and asked AI if it was AI-generated. AI agrees with my colleague:
“While the content is highly sophisticated and specific…, the structural and stylistic patterns are classic hallmarks of AI-generated text.
Why it looks like AI
- The “Perfect Academic” Tone: The writing is incredibly polished, polite, and grammatically flawless, but lacks the organic conversational quirks, slight imperfections, or unique voice usually found in human-written emails or forum posts.
- Predictable Structural Formulas: It uses standard AI transitions like “Ultimately, I think…”, “Taken together, I believe…”, and “A key challenge for [X], however, is…” to perfectly tie paragraphs together.
- The “Sandwich” Format: AI almost always starts and ends responses with polite, generic bookends (“Thank you so much for sharing…” and “Thank you again for sharing this. It gave me a great deal to think about.”).
- Comprehensive Bullet-Point Style (without actual bullets): The text exhaustively lists out every possible dimension of the campus experience (sacred images, residential living, Mass, OCIA, workforce entry, ethical leadership) in a perfectly balanced, symmetrical manner.”
So, in addition to not having a Catholic value-add, or true Catholic character, maybe things are far, far worse than I first thought.
“No,” another colleague tells me. “You’ve had a thoughtful response from someone who cares and knows.”
“I so want you to be correct.” She’s not, though, I’m pretty sure.
There is no uniform response to when we might use AI or even if we are using it.
My first colleague cautioned, “Everyone who is in a classroom now must constantly confront this possibility.”
But do we now need to ask professors and administrators, as we might college freshmen, “Did you write this or generate it?”
Then, “Is my concern too small to warrant a human response?”
Called to participate in God’s genius
Aristotle viewed art as an imitation of nature’s own creative processes revealing universal truths. In the art of conversation and writing, give and take, call and response, we seek fresh examination of issues, possibly yielding changes of heart, mind and attitude.
In the process and the exchange, we encounter souls just and unjust, on both of whom refreshing rain or thunderous storms fall. The exchange uncovers the sins and triumphs of souls and calls the thoughtful writer and reader to participate in an exchange that reveals God’s creative character and genius.
Perhaps a similar intent or understanding led the biblical author to hope “that in all things God may be glorified” (1 Peter 4:11).
Does AI change what we might hope for? My colleague later wrote, “I am constantly reflecting on how blessed I am that this problem only emerged at the end of my teaching career.”
Good for him. Bad for us. It’s a brave, new world. Maybe. I guess.
The New York Times reports (September 15, 2026) that “The worries that artificial intelligence is degrading education have been building for months. Students are using it for everything, including cheating, and a recent report from M.I.T. said it is triggering ‘cognitive surrender.’”
But, and alarmingly, “Many university leaders are embracing AI with enthusiasm anyway.” And, “AI can be hard to avoid.” Worse, “Students are often navigating this landscape without clear guidance from their colleges.”
One professor noted, “They will do it anyway.” She then asked, “How do we teach them responsible use?”
Not to worry. The Current Occupant of the U.S.A.’s White House weighed in on September 14, posting on Truth Social: “The only control or ‘guardrails’ that AI needs is a STRONG AND SMART (High IQ!) PRESIDENT, and the U.S.A. has that, in spades!”
Jimmy Fallon jumped on that on late-night television: “We’re relying on Trump to beat AI; I don’t even think Trump can beat Wordle.”
This is a moment when we need to hear from the Church. Pope Leo has weighed in with Magnifica Humanitas. Members of an audience we all wish were bigger are, as Leo asked, engaging technologists in discussion about the meaning of their work for humanity. Would that Catholic colleges and universities take the lead. If they are, I missed it.
Mulaney for the win
Besides Leo, you know who nailed it? Georgetown graduate John Mulaney. The American stand-up comic, actor, writer, and producer recently took the stage at the Emmys to present the award for Best Lead Actor in a Drama Series. To begin, he pulled out a borrowed public library book, A Guy’s Guide to Being a Man’s Man, a 2006 self-help guide by Frank Vincent.
Mulaney read from the text: “A man’s man can be wearing the best clothes, drinking the finest wine, sitting with the most beautiful woman in Las Vegas, but if he doesn’t treat everyone around him with respect and class, he’s not a real man’s man, he’s just a jabroni in a good suit.” He then announced the nominees. No pressure.
I had to look up jabroni: “an informal slang term for a foolish, contemptible person, loser, or a professional wrestler whose main job is to lose matches and make other wrestlers look good.”
Danger: careless use of AI could well make of our Catholic (or Catholic adjacent) academics jabronis in Geneva gowns.
Those jabronis will sometimes point, as their institutions become every year less and less identifiably Catholic and more and more secular, to some point of light to showcase what remains of the former identity, but it seems to be performative for, perhaps, the faithful remnant of the nuns on the Board.
Ventures with futures
We should note also that numbers of Newman Centers on secular campuses in the USA are doing remarkably good work. Look, for example, at the offerings at the New York University Catholic Center. Some might think that such ventures are the future of Catholic higher education.
Outstanding though they may be, they do not make up for the philosophy and theology jettisoned in favor of advanced seminars in How to Use Cash Registers and Credit Card Readers Efficiently and Effectively, In a Manner Consistent with the Catholic Tradition as It Is Mediated For Us by Our Value of Semper Fi.
I was thinking of such things one Friday in early December as I saw an undergraduate loading his car, ready to head home to Omaha, a six-hour drive.
“Where are you going?” I asked cluelessly. “Final exams are next week.”
“Oh, Father Bill,” he said gently before aiming at distant Nebraska, “I’m a business major.”
Kyrie eleison.














