Australia’s Big Tech crackdown signals the end of ‘anything goes’ culture
Australia’s push to regulate Big Tech harms reveals the limits of a permissive “anything goes” culture, hinting that regulation is a roundabout way of recovering a vision of the good.
Have we reached peak permissiveness? Australia’s current appetite for regulating Big Tech would suggest so.
Sure, the Albanese Government’s Digital Duty of Care (DDC) bill may principally be aimed at Silicon Valley, but our individual online habits, and how these spill offline, are also in the government’s sights. A sign, perhaps, that it’s time to tweak the setting that has long been our cultural default: a hands-off approach where anything goes, so long as everything’s legal and everyone’s consented.
For a long time that liberal, non-judgmental stance sounded fine in theory. But then our permissiveness was let loose on the internet where life online pledged similar commitments to openness, no boundaries or limits, the individual freely going where they willed. Free love met the free flow of information online.
Everyone did what was good in their eyes, which needn’t suit anyone else: live and let live. Follow your bliss.
But the very existence of the DDC bill suggests that the utopian vision of the early internet, which promised to free us from constraints, somewhat backfired. Maybe some desires should’ve stayed suppressed.
I imagine that in private, Plibersek would be more strident in her revulsion at those alarming stats. But to own those views publicly would veer into more self-consciously moralistic territory. If anything is off-limits in a permissive culture, it’s talk like that.
So, it seems significant that Plibersek, as schooled as any center-left politician in refraining from passing judgment, would even hint that consensual sexual choking wasn’t a good choice. She also proposed Australia should consider a UK-style ban (which began November 6) on pornography depicting the practice.
“We might finally be forced to say the presently unsayable: all choices are moral choices. Some choices are plain wrong. Just don’t ask us why – we lack the vocabulary for that conversation.”
The limits of consent
The DDC legislation puts us on the cusp of a bigger social reckoning. Inspired by consent activist Chanel Contos’ Fix our Feeds campaign, it puts the onus on tech companies to ensure the safety of their platforms for users, while also giving Australians greater control of their algorithmic feeds.
In its focus on the shaping effect of online environments, Contos’ latest campaign demonstrates that her ‘teach us consent’ advocacy was only the beginning. If consent education was the prime goal, then consent (even of the ongoing and enthusiastic variety) could be accused of being individualistic and choice-centric: fixated on someone’s ability to choose, and less concerned with whether good choices are available to them.
But Contos clearly has bigger game in her sights. As her original campaign declared, ‘social media algorithms are flooding young men’s feeds with radical misogynistic content, inciting real-world harm’.
What men are being ‘fed’ online, the campaign proposed, will constrain women’s choices – in the world in general, in the bedroom, and on the relationships front. (If they’re seeking partners, that is, and not abstaining because the choices are less than compelling.)
Under the current proposed bill, harmful content would be outlawed, including posts promoting eating disorders, bullying, and misogyny (for under-18s) and, for Australian adults, content involving child sexual exploitation, sexual violence, and incitement to terrorist violence. Nudify apps would be banned; also, likely, chatbot activity that encouraged emotional dependence on AI over people.
If the bill is passed, and I sincerely hope it will, that list of proscribed social evils will probably grow. Censorship isn’t so much the issue, but our reflex to regulate against anti-social behavior.
Of course, regulation is the mandate of every government. But it’s a hard needle to thread in a permissive age. We’re left juggling competing claims: wanting to minimize social harm while also maximizing individual freedom by leaving plenty of non-judgmental room for people to define their own good.
But on closer look, regulation seems a roundabout attempt to reverse-engineer that vision of the good we were reluctant to impose in the first place. A minimalist version of it, anyway.
Regulation aims to make us people who don’t strangle their partners during sex (even when asked), who don’t spout misogynistic rhetoric, who still prefer human to AI companions, despite their flaws. Maybe this is the best outcome a diverse and divided society can hope for.
The reckoning ahead
I suspect we’ll find out the hard way that regulation, while necessary, only gets us so far, and only for so long. The looming possibility of AI-generated pornography promises a future sexual landscape where bespoke sexual desires can finally let rip, unrestrained by the limits imposed by real-life humans, and consenting ones of legal age at that. If the porn of tomorrow doesn’t depict or hurt real people, then on what basis could the government appeal to ban such content?
We might finally be forced to say the presently unsayable: all choices are moral choices. Some choices are plain wrong. Just don’t ask us why – we lack the vocabulary for that conversation.
‘Everything is permissible, but not everything is beneficial’, the Apostle Paul wrote to the Corinthian church, in response to dominant ‘you do you’ attitudes of his time. As we second-guess our culture’s extreme permissiveness, then who knows? St Paul’s catchphrase might make a comeback.
This column first appeared in Eureka Street and is republished by Global Catholic with permission.
Hope you loved reading this article. Global Catholic is powered by readers like you.
We have no corporate owner or funding agencies. Our in-depth commentaries, features and conversations are not behind the paywall.
We don’t carry advertisements as we want to offer a clutter-free reading experience.
To sustain and grow Global Catholic, we need to raise US$250,000.
Having retraced Francis’s legacy from Uruguay to Argentina, Leo casts his South American journey as traveling in reverse the road his predecessor once walked.
The midterm rebuke to Trumpism offers the Church a chance to free itself from ideological captivity, from the partisan entanglements that distorted its moral and social teaching.
Pope Leo XIV received Bob Dylan, an encounter rich with history, between a pope shaped by Augustine and the Bible, and a songwriter who has spoken Scripture for sixty years.
Trump’s midterm defeat raises an uncomfortable question: did Americans repudiate Trumpism or just high fuel prices, and what would it mean to truly “humanate,” to live by Christ’s selfless love?
The kerygma is God’s infinite love, and what truly attracts people to faith is not dogmatic orthodoxy but Christians who live that love toward the rejected and the suffering.
As tech companies turn to religion for moral guidance, the real question is not whether machines can gain a conscience, but whether humanity has conscience enough to govern artificial intelligence.
Australia’s Big Tech crackdown signals the end of ‘anything goes’ culture
Google Search
Subscribe to Newsletter
Have we reached peak permissiveness? Australia’s current appetite for regulating Big Tech would suggest so.
Sure, the Albanese Government’s Digital Duty of Care (DDC) bill may principally be aimed at Silicon Valley, but our individual online habits, and how these spill offline, are also in the government’s sights. A sign, perhaps, that it’s time to tweak the setting that has long been our cultural default: a hands-off approach where anything goes, so long as everything’s legal and everyone’s consented.
For a long time that liberal, non-judgmental stance sounded fine in theory. But then our permissiveness was let loose on the internet where life online pledged similar commitments to openness, no boundaries or limits, the individual freely going where they willed. Free love met the free flow of information online.
Everyone did what was good in their eyes, which needn’t suit anyone else: live and let live. Follow your bliss.
But the very existence of the DDC bill suggests that the utopian vision of the early internet, which promised to free us from constraints, somewhat backfired. Maybe some desires should’ve stayed suppressed.
One example from earlier this year: after the death of a 16-year-old girl by suspected (and consensual) sexual strangulation, Social Services MP Tanya Plibersek took pains to clarify that ‘there is no safe way to strangle someone’ during sex.
That ‘safe’ word does all the heavy lifting there. Sexual strangulation, previously a fringe practice, is now widely depicted in porn and part of the sexual ‘playbook’ for Australian young adults, with one 2024 study finding that 57 percent of 18–35-year-olds had been strangled during sex.
I imagine that in private, Plibersek would be more strident in her revulsion at those alarming stats. But to own those views publicly would veer into more self-consciously moralistic territory. If anything is off-limits in a permissive culture, it’s talk like that.
So, it seems significant that Plibersek, as schooled as any center-left politician in refraining from passing judgment, would even hint that consensual sexual choking wasn’t a good choice. She also proposed Australia should consider a UK-style ban (which began November 6) on pornography depicting the practice.
“We might finally be forced to say the presently unsayable: all choices are moral choices. Some choices are plain wrong. Just don’t ask us why – we lack the vocabulary for that conversation.”
The limits of consent
The DDC legislation puts us on the cusp of a bigger social reckoning. Inspired by consent activist Chanel Contos’ Fix our Feeds campaign, it puts the onus on tech companies to ensure the safety of their platforms for users, while also giving Australians greater control of their algorithmic feeds.
In its focus on the shaping effect of online environments, Contos’ latest campaign demonstrates that her ‘teach us consent’ advocacy was only the beginning. If consent education was the prime goal, then consent (even of the ongoing and enthusiastic variety) could be accused of being individualistic and choice-centric: fixated on someone’s ability to choose, and less concerned with whether good choices are available to them.
But Contos clearly has bigger game in her sights. As her original campaign declared, ‘social media algorithms are flooding young men’s feeds with radical misogynistic content, inciting real-world harm’.
What men are being ‘fed’ online, the campaign proposed, will constrain women’s choices – in the world in general, in the bedroom, and on the relationships front. (If they’re seeking partners, that is, and not abstaining because the choices are less than compelling.)
Under the current proposed bill, harmful content would be outlawed, including posts promoting eating disorders, bullying, and misogyny (for under-18s) and, for Australian adults, content involving child sexual exploitation, sexual violence, and incitement to terrorist violence. Nudify apps would be banned; also, likely, chatbot activity that encouraged emotional dependence on AI over people.
If the bill is passed, and I sincerely hope it will, that list of proscribed social evils will probably grow. Censorship isn’t so much the issue, but our reflex to regulate against anti-social behavior.
Of course, regulation is the mandate of every government. But it’s a hard needle to thread in a permissive age. We’re left juggling competing claims: wanting to minimize social harm while also maximizing individual freedom by leaving plenty of non-judgmental room for people to define their own good.
But on closer look, regulation seems a roundabout attempt to reverse-engineer that vision of the good we were reluctant to impose in the first place. A minimalist version of it, anyway.
Regulation aims to make us people who don’t strangle their partners during sex (even when asked), who don’t spout misogynistic rhetoric, who still prefer human to AI companions, despite their flaws. Maybe this is the best outcome a diverse and divided society can hope for.
The reckoning ahead
I suspect we’ll find out the hard way that regulation, while necessary, only gets us so far, and only for so long. The looming possibility of AI-generated pornography promises a future sexual landscape where bespoke sexual desires can finally let rip, unrestrained by the limits imposed by real-life humans, and consenting ones of legal age at that. If the porn of tomorrow doesn’t depict or hurt real people, then on what basis could the government appeal to ban such content?
We might finally be forced to say the presently unsayable: all choices are moral choices. Some choices are plain wrong. Just don’t ask us why – we lack the vocabulary for that conversation.
‘Everything is permissible, but not everything is beneficial’, the Apostle Paul wrote to the Corinthian church, in response to dominant ‘you do you’ attitudes of his time. As we second-guess our culture’s extreme permissiveness, then who knows? St Paul’s catchphrase might make a comeback.
This column first appeared in Eureka Street and is republished by Global Catholic with permission.
Hope you loved reading this article. Global Catholic is powered by readers like you.
We have no corporate owner or funding agencies. Our in-depth commentaries, features and conversations are not behind the paywall.
We don’t carry advertisements as we want to offer a clutter-free reading experience.
To sustain and grow Global Catholic, we need to raise US$250,000.
Join the remarkable Global Catholic journey
VATICAN DIARY
Leo carries Francis’ legacy through Latin America
SIGNS OF THE TIMES
US midterms: A liberating invitation for the US Church
WAYPOINTS
Bob Dylan and Pope Leo: two ‘Augustinians’
GRIMMGRAM
An election and ‘humanating’
LIGHTS AND SHADOWS
Love: Most authentic force of evangelization
MORALITY MATTERS
Can Artificial Intelligence have a conscience?
Latest
Australia’s Big Tech crackdown signals the end of ‘anything goes’ culture
Catholic Social Teaching and the non-person
Why the political right weaponizes ‘family,’ and how the left should answer
‘I lived with a saint’: Carlo Acutis’ mother remembers her son
The age of deference is over, even in the Church
‘My Mass’: two words that reveal a deeper problem
Trending
Can Artificial Intelligence have a conscience?
Leo carries Francis’ legacy through Latin America
Why the German Church still wrestles with its liturgical translations from Latin
Neither flight, nor flag: Benedict, Dominic and the Council
Mega Anthropic IPO: Should Christians invest?
Council of Crete at 10: The unfinished work of Christian unity
America rejected Trump, yet he governs on: what happens now?
Should the Church still speak of ‘heresy’?
From spy chief to Vatican envoy: Germany’s ambassador on Pope Leo
Synodal reform redesigns the table, but forgets some chairs