Why Pope Leo XIV’s honesty about his health matters

Pope Leo XIV’s candor about his cancer surgery marks a striking break from the Vatican’s old culture of concealment, recalled by a reporter once silenced for writing about John Paul II’s hidden illnesses.
General view of St. Peter's Basilica during the evening. (Photo: Duc Tinh Ngo / Pexels)
General view of St. Peter’s Basilica during the evening. (Photo: Duc Tinh Ngo / Pexels)

Subscribe to Newsletter

    One of the aspects of Leo XIV that impresses me most is his unusual combination of simplicity, sobriety and transparency.

    The pope revealed a lung nodule to the faithful during his Sunday blessing on Oct. 11, 2026, and underwent surgery to remove it two days later at Rome’s Gemelli Hospital, as reported by the Associated Press and multiple outlets.

    He then proceeded, as planned, with his first Latin American trip as pontiff — to Uruguay, Argentina and Peru, running Nov. 6–17 — with the Holy See Press Office confirming he remained clinically fit to travel.

    For precisely one of the scourges that has long plagued the Vatican’s institutional machinery is the concealment of its “shameful secrets.” That is, until Pope Francis arrived with his disruptive, Gospel-inspired approach.

    His creative, intuitive style and closeness to ordinary people won him many supporters and followers among the public, including nonbelievers. The great interest with which many of his catechetical conversations continue to be shared on social media, even after his death, is proof of this.

    It is true that some of the more conservative people “on the inside” did not readily accept his plainspoken, direct, friendly and unceremonious style.

    They were, and still are, those who continue to identify the Petrine ministry — the pope’s role as successor to St. Peter — with pomp and magnificence. Yet, thanks to this approach and his authenticity, Francis brought the Church closer to the poor, the marginalized, the sick, children and the elderly.

    He tried to lead it away from the terror of the sacred and toward the language and love of the little ones, and to take it to the Gospel’s field hospital. He was not afraid of the truth.

    Now we have just witnessed another giant step forward by Pope Prevost in the way he has handled his illness.

    Wojtyla’s illness: a “top secret”

    In this regard, it is worth recalling the small ordeal I went through as a reporter when covering the serious illnesses John Paul II — born Karol Wojtyla — suffered during his final years.

    His health became one of the Vatican’s best-kept secrets. I remember the words: “We can no longer keep saying the same thing. We have to give people an explanation,” Cardinal Secretary of State Angelo Sodano whispered to the official spokesman, Joaquín Navarro-Valls, a Spaniard and a physician by profession.

    The cardinal had seen what everyone else had seen on television during the pope’s trip to Hungary: a hesitant, trembling, exhausted pope, his face showing pain, who had to abruptly interrupt his speech at Pannonhalma Abbey — a Benedictine monastery in western Hungary — and lean against the crossing of the church’s apse. Speculation once again soared around the world.

    Senior officials in the Vatican hierarchy decided that something had to be said. For the Spanish Opus Dei member — Opus Dei is a Catholic institution emphasizing the sanctification of ordinary work and life — who directed the Vatican Press Office and was one of Wojtyla’s three closest friends, alongside his Polish secretary and a Vietnamese bishop, the decision was difficult: How could he face public opinion after officially and systematically denying all rumors and reports of the pope’s serious illnesses?

    Navarro chose to acknowledge that John Paul II was ill, but offered an ambiguous response that would justify his repeated denials. “The pope has a bacterial infection of unknown origin, but he is basically a healthy man. His weakness should be attributed to the antibiotics.”

    To support this explanation, he referred to the pope’s packed schedule of upcoming trips.

    Behind it all, undoubtedly, was the tremendous willpower and spirit of sacrifice of the tough Karol Wojtyla, who had lived through Nazi and Communist resistance, the successive deaths of his loved ones, and the proximity of concentration camps.

    According to his aides, some of whom considered these exhausting trips inhuman, “he is the one who insists on continuing to travel.” His model, after all, was the martyred bishop of Kraków, St. Stanislaus.

    The truth is that the pope’s marked weakness had not begun just two months earlier, nor was it caused by an infection of unknown origin, as official sources claimed.

    Dr. Javier López Soane, a digestive-system specialist, told Tiempo magazine: “Just by looking at him, the pope is not a healthy man. The argument is simple: he is tired and he is 75 years old. At that age, with that workload, a person can still be in good health.”

    Moreover, this doctor and others consulted pointed out that bacterial intestinal infections in adults — especially in the case of an elderly pope whose food and drink are subject to particularly careful controls — are rare and almost always identifiable, not “mysterious.” His appearance, they said, was that of a chronically ill person.

    López Soane agreed with the position taken by a group of American doctors who, following the 1992 operation to remove a colon tumor the size of an orange, declared that “a tumor of those proportions could not be benign.”

    In Brazil, at the same time that rumors of possible Parkinson’s disease were circulating, an unusual incident had occurred two years earlier: Cardinal Aloísio Lorscheider told Radio Fortaleza that the pope had cancer.

    The following day, the cardinal himself was forced to retract the statement on the radio station. Regarding the Parkinson’s hypothesis, which Vatican spokesman Navarro-Valls had denied two years earlier, he took another step back, acknowledging that “the hand tremor is of extrapyramidal origin” — a neurological term referring to the brain’s motor-control pathways, commonly associated with Parkinson’s disease.

    Doctors consulted by the Italian press said that this terminology did not rule out Parkinson’s disease.

    Ironclad bad health

    The health problems of the seemingly indestructible and hyperactive Wojtyla began, according to the accounts of his biographers — Polish-American Tad Szulc and myself, author of Hombre y Papa — in 1959, when he was a young auxiliary bishop of Kraków.

    Dr. Stanisław Kownacki diagnosed him with mononucleosis, a blood disease caused by a virus. This infection attacks the lymph glands and causes an excessive production of white blood cells, known in medicine as “monocytes.”

    The disease can be cured once the infection has run its course, but it can also recur or become chronic. From then on, Monsignor Wojtyla began doing even more sports than he had already been doing, following medical advice.

    After all, everyone knows the rest of his medical history: vacations because of migraines, the construction of a swimming pool, and the 1981 shooting in the abdomen by the lowlife Mehmet Ali Agca.

    Surgeon Francesco Crucetti said at the time: “We began the operation with anguish; we were racing against death. When we opened him up, his abdomen was full of blood. He had lost more than three liters … We had to remove 55 centimeters of intestine and give him a transfusion.” The operation lasted five hours and 20 minutes.

    Just when he seemed to be recovering, he had to be admitted to the Gemelli Hospital again on June 20. Doctors diagnosed a cytomegalovirus infection, which he had contracted through the transfusion of three liters of blood during the operation.

    Professor Crucetti then admitted: “In the hospital, during those final days, he was like a caged lion.”

    On July 12, 1992, the pope himself astonished the world by announcing during the Angelus that he would be admitted to the hospital. After the precancerous tumor was removed on July 15, specialists were forced to reopen the old scar running from his chest to his groin.

    Along the way, they discovered gallstones, so they also removed his gallbladder. Spokesman Navarro-Valls acknowledged this. The medical report left no room for doubt. It referred to a “tubulovillous adenoma of the sigmoid colon, with modest and localized cytological changes, corresponding to moderate dysplasia.”

    But subsequent medical bulletins made no mention of anticancer treatment, since the base of the polyp was not malignant.

    After traveling to Santo Domingo, on Nov. 11, 1993, Karol Wojtyla stepped on his cassock and fell in the Hall of Blessings after an audience with the FAO — the United Nations’ Food and Agriculture Organization, headquartered in Rome — dislocating his right shoulder and suffering a small fracture.

    The injury was treated under general anesthesia, and his arm was immobilized. Despite this, and against his doctors’ advice, Wojtyla went skiing again less than three months after the operation.

    That same year, during his visit to Spain, a meal with King Juan Carlos and Queen Sofía was canceled to prevent them from seeing his hand tremble as he used his cutlery. This detail was kept so secret that no news outlet had made it public until then.

    “Reporting forbidden”

    In May of that year, I received an urgent phone call. It was from the provincial superior of the Society of Jesus in Spain. It was the second call in less than a month.

    The first had been to summon me to a meeting at which he asked me, on behalf of the superior general, Dutchman Peter-Hans Kolvenbach, to explain my book Hombre y Papa, an exhaustive biography of John Paul II published by Espasa Calpe and subject to censorship.

    The book, which its author described as “affectionate toward its subject, but not papolatrous,” had displeased the then-prefect of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith — the Vatican office responsible for safeguarding Catholic doctrine — Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, later Pope Benedict XVI.

    I explained then that writing the book had helped me understand my subject better, and that the same was true of many people who were distant from the Catholic Church. This time, Provincial Superior Melecio Agúndez was calling to give me worse news.

    My article “The Thousand Mysteries of the Pope’s Illness,” which explored the possibility of cancer and had been published in Diario 16, had caused an uproar because of its worldwide distribution by Agence France-Presse.

    The provincial superior showed me two letters: one from Vatican Secretary of State Cardinal Sodano and the other from the superior general of the Jesuits.

    The Holy See’s “number two” was asking the Jesuit superior to silence Lamet, while the superior general was ordering his subordinate “to submit his writings to prior censorship or, if he refused to accept it, to leave the Society of Jesus.”

    This was not an isolated incident. It must be understood within what we have called “the years of the gag,” when John Paul II governed the Church with an iron hand, pushing it into a reversal of the Second Vatican Council. Theologians, professors, base communities, open-minded bishops, writers and journalists all suffered firsthand.

    At the time, I was editor of Vida Nueva, a columnist for Diario 16 and the author of 20 books. I chose to obey and offered to write about nonreligious subjects for another newspaper, since prior censorship was technically incompatible with the immediacy required by journalistic work. The provincial superior accepted.

    Colleagues in religious journalism sent letters of protest to the Spanish Bishops’ Conference and the Society of Jesus. It was all in vain.

    When Tiempo asked me about the pope’s health, I replied: “I said then what I had to say. I am not allowed to speak about this subject. But I still cannot understand why children are forbidden to take an interest in their father’s health, especially when he is also a public figure. I believe this is a political issue, not a Gospel issue, and the facts will speak for themselves. I wish this pope, whom I admire, a long and fruitful life, as anyone who reads my book can see. But that does not change the fact that he is a man, not a god.”

    And that is how I closed the matter.

    New steps toward humanizing a pope

    I have decided to dust off these memories, not for personal reasons, which I have long since put behind me. On the contrary, that small trial helped me grow in faith and hope. I want to make clear to pessimists that the Church is moving forward, even if it may not seem so.

    With Leo XIV, in my view, following in Francis’ footsteps, these fruitful steps are being taken:

    1. The current pope has the good sense to present himself as “an ordinary man.” With faith and his vocation as universal pastor, of course, but he does not try to conceal his fragility, much less his illness. If he is a father, his children have a right to know about it. Another sign of normality has been his voting in his country’s elections, like any democratic American citizen. And this applies to every aspect of human life.
    2. At bottom, concealment is a form of pride and arrogance, more characteristic of a prince than a pastor, and unbecoming of the Church and its vocation to truth. Jesus did not hide his own profound human suffering. He never shut himself away or withdrew from his people, except to communicate with the Father.
    3. The pope does not speak only to the community of believers. His voice is heard throughout the world as that of an international leader. Francis knew this and spoke to people’s hearts. Leo knows it too, and in addition to evangelizing, he addresses humanity with the sobriety of a lucid, restrained intellectual, speaking to people of goodwill of every age, culture and background.
    4. One of the most appealing aspects of the Augustinian pope — Leo XIV is a member of the Order of St. Augustine, the first Augustinian pope — is that he is not at all self-promoting. Behind his words lies an eloquent silence, an inner spirituality that is invisible yet perceptible. He has the virtue of setting his “ego” aside, which lends him great credibility.
    5. He says only what is necessary. He carefully crafts his words. He studies every speech extensively. He precisely gauges the context and the audience he is addressing. Will he not make the major changes some progressive theologians predict? Peter’s boat is being tossed about amid an enormous global storm. What more can he do than take hold of Peter’s helm with care and wisdom so that the boat does not sink?

    All this is being confirmed by the gestures, celebrations and speeches during his ongoing trip to Latin America — his first as pontiff, taking him to Uruguay, Argentina and his former diocese of Chiclayo, Peru, where he served as bishop from 2015 to 2023, as reported by Vatican News and Andina.

    Consider this statement he made to religious men and women, which applies to every human being, including the pope: “The more a person truly knows himself, while taking care of his own dignity, the closer he comes to God.”

    “The truth will set you free” (John 8:32).

    This is a translated and edited version of the column that first appeared on Religion Digital and has been republished with permission.

     

    Hope you loved reading this article. Global Catholic is powered by readers like you.

    We have no corporate owner or funding agencies. Our in-depth commentaries, features and conversations are not behind the paywall.

    We don’t carry advertisements as we want to offer a clutter-free reading experience.

    To sustain and grow Global Catholic, we need to raise US$250,000.

    Join the remarkable Global Catholic journey

    Share your comments

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    Pope Leo XIV welcomes Bob Dylan (third left) at the Vatican City alongside Fr. Antonio Spadaro (left). (Photo supplied)

    Bob Dylan and Pope Leo: two ‘Augustinians’

    Pope Leo XIV received Bob Dylan, an encounter rich with history, between a pope shaped by Augustine and the Bible, and a songwriter who has spoken Scripture for sixty years.
    Former US President Barack Obama (center) stands on stage with Democratic candidates Abdul El-Sayed (left) and Jocelyn Benson at a campaign rally in Detroit, Michigan. (Photo: Facebook/Democrats)

    An election and ‘humanating’

    Trump’s midterm defeat raises an uncomfortable question: did Americans repudiate Trumpism or just high fuel prices, and what would it mean to truly “humanate,” to live by Christ’s selfless love?
    A Christian man engaged in street ministry is seen holding a placard with a bible verse on God's love. (Photo: Pexels)

    Love: Most authentic force of evangelization

    The kerygma is God’s infinite love, and what truly attracts people to faith is not dogmatic orthodoxy but Christians who live that love toward the rejected and the suffering.
    Join the remarkable Global Catholic journey

    Join the remarkable Global Catholic journey

    Global Catholic is proud to be independent—editorially, politically, ideologically and financially.

    But independence comes at a cost. Without patron support, we depend entirely on readers and friends like you.

    To sustain and grow Global Catholic, we need to raise US$250,000.