Project Global Catholic

Who is raising our children: the family or the algorithm?

Meta’s landmark $18-billion settlement enforcing screen limits for teens compels parents and governments to resist attention-driven algorithms and protect childhood development.
Children are seen using their mobile phones. (Photo: Canva)
Children are seen using their mobile phones. (Photo: Canva)
Follow Global Catholic on
Google Search

Subscribe to Newsletter

    Something extraordinary happened recently in the United States.

    Meta, the company behind Facebook and Instagram, agreed to pay up to about US$18 billion to settle lawsuits brought by a large coalition of American states and territories. The cases accused the company of designing social-media products that kept children and teenagers engaged while failing adequately to protect them from harm.

    But the money may not be the most important part of the settlement.

    Meta has also agreed to something that would have sounded unthinkable a few years ago: teenagers under 18 will face a default limit of two hours a day across Facebook and Instagram. After reaching that limit, they will need parental permission to continue. Access to feeds, stories, explore and reels will normally be blocked between midnight and 6 a.m. Notifications will be muted during school hours, and young users will receive reminders after every 15 minutes of continuous use.

    The company that spent years perfecting technologies for keeping people online is now legally committing itself to helping teenagers stop scrolling.

    That should make every parent pause.

    When two hours becomes a safety measure

    Meta’s agreement is not an admission that Facebook or Instagram causes every problem associated with adolescent mental health. The company continues to dispute many allegations against it.

    Yet the scale of the settlement tells us something important.

    The debate has moved beyond whether excessive social-media use might be a problem. Governments, courts, parents and even technology companies themselves are increasingly accepting that children need protection from digital environments specifically designed to hold attention.

    Meta’s new rules also include age-verification measures, stronger parental supervision, and the option of chronological rather than algorithmically personalized feeds across Instagram and Facebook. Most of these provisions are expected to remain for a decade.

    The irony is striking.

    For years, parents were told that screen discipline was essentially their responsibility: control your child, set household rules and teach moderation.

    Now the platforms themselves are being compelled to build moderation into their architecture.

    Perhaps we have finally recognized that asking a fourteen-year-old to resist an algorithm created by some of the world’s finest engineers is not a fair contest.

    India should pay attention

    India has a particular reason to watch this development.

    The Annual Status of Education Report 2024 found that 89.1 percent of rural Indian adolescents aged 14–16 had access to a smartphone at home and 82.2 percent knew how to use one. Among those who could use smartphones, 76 percent had used social media during the preceding week, while only 57 percent had used their phones for an educational activity.

    The smartphone has therefore ceased to be merely another household appliance.

    For a growing number of Indian children, it is becoming the place where friendships are made, identities tested, entertainment consumed, products advertised, comparisons made and approval sought.

    India is beginning to respond. Its data-protection framework imposes special obligations regarding children’s personal information and restricts behavioral tracking and targeted advertising involving minors. Parliament has also seen proposals for stronger age verification and parental consent, while deep fakes and synthetic sexual imagery have created a new generation of child-safety concerns.

    But regulation alone cannot answer the deeper question.

    What kind of childhood do we want?

    Other Countries Are Already Drawing Boundaries

    Australia has taken perhaps the strongest step. Since Dec. 10, 2025, major social media companies have been required to take reasonable measures to stop Australians under 16 from maintaining accounts on designated platforms. Companies that seriously fail to comply can face penalties running into tens of millions of Australian dollars.

    France has pursued another model. From the 2026–27 school year, its policy extends phone-free schooling across primary and secondary education, with limited exceptions.

    Greece has announced plans for a 15-year minimum age for social-media access from January 2027, while Norway and Denmark have been considering similar age thresholds.

    The details differ from country to country. Some policies are enacted laws; others are developing proposals.

    But the direction is unmistakable.

    Societies that enthusiastically placed digital technology in children’s hands are beginning to ask whether they moved too quickly.

    Even technology’s pioneers were cautious

    There is a revealing contradiction much closer to Silicon Valley.

    Bill Gates, who helped bring personal computing into homes across the world, said that his children were not given mobile phones until they were 14. He also described rules banning phones from the family dinner table and restricting screen use before bedtime.

    Steve Jobs was even more striking.

    When New York Times journalist Nick Bilton asked Jobs in 2010 whether his children loved the newly released iPad, Jobs replied that they had not used it and that his family limited how much technology the children used at home.

    Jobs’ biographer Walter Isaacson later recalled evenings in the Jobs household centred on dinner-table conversations about books, history and other subjects rather than screens.

    These anecdotes should not be exaggerated. Gates and Jobs did not reject technology, and neither provides a universal parenting formula.

    But their caution deserves attention.

    People who understood digital technology exceptionally well apparently did not assume that unlimited access would necessarily benefit their own children.

    The child has become an attention commodity

    The real ethical problem is not the smartphone.

    A smartphone can educate, connect, translate, entertain and even protect. For many children, it provides extraordinary access to knowledge.

    The deeper problem is the business model of attention.

    Social-media platforms succeed commercially when people remain on them. The system therefore learns what makes users pause, click, react, return and continue scrolling.

    ❝

    When some of technology’s most successful pioneers placed firm limits around screens in their own homes, perhaps the rest of us should reconsider the assumption that unlimited connectivity represents progress.

    For adults, resisting this machinery can already be difficult.

    For children—whose capacities for self-regulation, judgment and impulse control are still developing—the imbalance is much greater.

    The child is no longer merely a user.

    She is also a consumer to whom products can be sold, a producer of behavioural data and a source of attention that can be monetised.

    This is why Meta’s two-hour limit is philosophically significant.

    It indirectly acknowledges something society has been reluctant to say: more engagement is not always better engagement.

    Sometimes a responsible technology company must actually encourage its customer to leave.

    We would not treat other risks this way

    Imagine telling a twelve-year-old that unlimited access to gambling was acceptable provided his parents taught him self-control.

    We would regard that as absurd.

    Societies restrict alcohol, tobacco, driving and gambling because children and adolescents have a special claim to protection.

    Yet for years we have treated some of the world’s most sophisticated attention-capturing technologies differently. We have placed the device in the child’s bedroom and transferred responsibility almost entirely to the family.

    Meta’s settlement begins to reverse that assumption.

    Parents remain responsible. But corporations also have responsibilities because they design the environment in which choices are made.

    What does Christianity owe the child?

    Here the Christian tradition has something important to contribute.

    Jesus repeatedly places the vulnerable at the center of moral responsibility. His attitude toward children is particularly striking. Children are not valued because they produce, purchase, vote or contribute economically. They possess dignity simply because they are persons entrusted to our care.

    That changes the digital question.

    Instead of asking only, “How much screen time should children be allowed,” Christians should ask, “What do adults owe children in order for them to become fully human?”

    We owe them periods of boredom in which imagination can grow.

    We owe them face-to-face friendship.

    We owe them meals where nobody is looking downward at a screen.

    We owe them sleep uninterrupted by notifications.

    We owe them opportunities to play, read, argue, pray, explore nature and discover themselves without continuously performing for an audience.

    Most importantly, we owe children the right not to have every vulnerable moment converted into commercial data.

    Parents must also look at their own phones

    It is easy to blame Meta, Instagram or TikTok.

    The more uncomfortable examination begins at home.

    A father cannot convincingly tell his daughter to put away her phone while checking WhatsApp every three minutes. A mother cannot teach digital restraint if every moment of silence is immediately filled by scrolling.

    Children learn digital habits partly by watching adults.

    Perhaps the most effective parental control is sometimes not an application installed on the child’s phone, but a habit practised on the parent’s phone.

    Families might reconsider phones at meals, devices in bedrooms, unrestricted late-night access and the age at which children receive personal smartphones.

    Churches and schools can help by creating genuine phone-free spaces and treating digital formation as part of moral and human formation.

    Childhood happens only once

    The Meta settlement could become a turning point.

    A company valued in the trillions has agreed to pay billions and redesign significant aspects of its platforms for young users. Whether these measures will prove sufficient remains disputed, and some critics argue that Meta’s underlying engagement-driven business model remains largely untouched.

    But the message for India should be clear.

    The central question is no longer whether children should participate in the digital world. They already do.

    The question is who sets the terms of that participation.

    Will it be parents, schools, communities and governments acting in the child’s interests?

    Or will it be algorithms whose principal measure of success is how long the child remains watching?

    Technology should serve childhood.

    Childhood should never be redesigned to serve technology.

    When even Meta accepts that two hours may be enough, and when some of technology’s most successful pioneers placed firm limits around screens in their own homes, perhaps the rest of us should reconsider the assumption that unlimited connectivity represents progress.

    Children require technology, certainly.

    But they require something much more urgently: adults willing to protect the space in which they can become human.

    Hope you loved reading this article. Global Catholic is powered by readers like you.

    We have no corporate owner or funding agencies. Our in-depth commentaries, features and conversations are not behind the paywall.

    We don’t carry advertisements as we want to offer a clutter-free reading experience.

    To sustain and grow Global Catholic, we need to raise US$250,000.

    Join the remarkable Global Catholic journey

    Share your comments

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    Pope Leo XIV welcomes Bob Dylan (third left) at the Vatican City alongside Fr. Antonio Spadaro (left). (Photo supplied)

    Bob Dylan and Pope Leo: two ‘Augustinians’

    Pope Leo XIV received Bob Dylan, an encounter rich with history, between a pope shaped by Augustine and the Bible, and a songwriter who has spoken Scripture for sixty years.
    Former US President Barack Obama (center) stands on stage with Democratic candidates Abdul El-Sayed (left) and Jocelyn Benson at a campaign rally in Detroit, Michigan. (Photo: Facebook/Democrats)

    An election and ‘humanating’

    Trump’s midterm defeat raises an uncomfortable question: did Americans repudiate Trumpism or just high fuel prices, and what would it mean to truly “humanate,” to live by Christ’s selfless love?
    A Christian man engaged in street ministry is seen holding a placard with a bible verse on God's love. (Photo: Pexels)

    Love: Most authentic force of evangelization

    The kerygma is God’s infinite love, and what truly attracts people to faith is not dogmatic orthodoxy but Christians who live that love toward the rejected and the suffering.

    Trending

    Join the remarkable Global Catholic journey

    Join the remarkable Global Catholic journey

    Global Catholic is proud to be independent—editorially, politically, ideologically and financially.

    But independence comes at a cost. Without patron support, we depend entirely on readers and friends like you.

    To sustain and grow Global Catholic, we need to raise US$250,000.