China and America in a burning world: A new philosophical-theological reflection
Addressing the global ecological crisis requires moving beyond economic exploitation to integrate philosophical framework, ecological law, and open intercultural diplomacy.
In Europe this summer, there have been three heat waves unprecedented in their early onset, intensity, duration, and geographical expanse. The health impacts on humans, animals, and plants have been dramatic, exacerbating the impacts of inequality associated with housing, working conditions, transportation, and income.
In Canada, my own country, forest wildfires have been raging, requiring the evacuation of communities and exhausting firefighters and their resources. It is reported that in Ontario alone, by early summer, more land had been burned than in all of last year’s fires combined. Though many of the fires are in less populated areas, the air pollution from these fires reaches densely populated areas across North America, causing periods of apocalyptic gloom.
Edward Schillebeeckx OP has been widely noted to have been one of the most competent and courageous theologians able and willing to confront the creative, though often troublesome, tension between Christian doctrine and biblical scholarship.
Schillebeeckx once pointed out in his book Christ: The Experience of Jesus as Lord (1983) that the theology of the oppressed is not the theology of the converted … and that both have something important to say.
Whereas the dialogue partner of most Western European theology has been the unbeliever, as in the unbelieving humanist, the conversation partner of most non-Western theology has been the oppressed, the person held in subjection as the victim of our societal systems.
Schillebeeckx says it is precisely here that we have the modern problem of oppression for this present phase of the development of human consciousness. We are concerned about fellow human beings and the nature we all depend upon to live and that now suffers together an exploitation and oppression not only from other human beings, but more significantly from a socioeconomic and political system that now seemingly operates as an almost anonymous force that nonetheless is very real in its human and natural consequences.
The consequences now are such that previous distinctions between economic, social, ecological, and even spiritual or mental exploitation and oppression are tending to be less and less obvious.
Our dominant economic development model and practices increasingly are seen to be threatening more and more people’s actual living conditions and the natural conditions required for their just livelihood. This is a constant and mounting situation of oppression in our present circumstances that seems to make it impossible for the individual from the very outset to find the time or energy to become righteous.
This is not suffering for the Kingdom of God or for the good cause. It is simply dumb suffering. This, says Schillebeeckx, writing nearly 50 years ago, is or should be our new situation of theological awareness. It is very new in relation to what the Bible mostly says except in relation to the oldest Biblical story of the Hebrews’ lamentation over their slavery and an associated idolatry, which was what caused God to come and be among his people whether they be holy or not.
There are similar New Testament impulses, says Schillebeeckx, that have not yet fully emerged because of the Church’s self-focus rather than focusing on the prophet Jesus. The Church has tended to identify itself as the body of Christ, thereby failing to do justice to the real concerns of Ephesians and Colossians.
There is this new modern consciousness that rightly articulates itself in what has been called “human rights” of all, and not only of the good and just, not only of the members of the household of faith.
Schillebeeckx says that the New Testament rejects such a one-sidedness, asserting clearly that “the living God is the savior of all” as well as “of those who believe” (1 Tim. 4:10).
A political backlash against climate action
So now we have a global situation that is widely agreed to have been foreseeable and warned about in successive UN IPCC reports. The solutions also have been well known – that we must immediately and urgently reduce greenhouse gas emissions and phase out the use of fossil fuels as quickly as possible.
However, there has been in certain quarters and among certain well-endowed groups, particularly among the billionaire class, a significant rise in opposition to climate policies and environmental protection, and so investment in oil and natural gas continues.
It is reported that finance capital interests even increased their investment in fossil fuel development in 2024-2025. This backlash and backtracking by existing political leaders and governments on environmental protection have been led by forces in the US, where both denial and obscurantism have been intensified under Trump’s presidency.
Closer to home in Canada, for example, strikingly under Mark Carney’s new Liberal government, fossil fuel lobbyists have been able to meet with government officials an unprecedented 1,300 times during Carney’s first year in office, amounting to approximately five points of contact per working day.
Close observers and analysts now see a serious rift between the interests of capital and the interests of science.
This apparent ideological challenge is seen as also presenting a strategic opportunity to confront what now is looking very much like “state-sponsored criminality,” where even in certain instances recent court rulings are ignored and there seems to be a systematic and widespread readiness on the part of the ruling classes to sacrifice human civilization and the riches and beauty of nature for the sake of this economic system and its seemingly anonymous force and logic that Schillebeeckx reflected upon theologically not that long ago.
In France, many scientists, doctors, researchers, philosophers, and artists have called for a “climate emergency law” that would prevent companies from participating in any new fossil fuel projects — coal mines, gas fields, oil wells. It would also abolish all subsidies for fossil fuels.
❝
Though the world survived [the] first Cold War, there are serious doubts about being able to survive a second one because of the grave economic and ecological consequences, along with the real risks for planetary life posed by thermonuclear war.
China’s search for an ecological civilization
China also has had to face serious environmental issues. These problems increased with China’s ascendance as the world’s second-largest economy. And yet there has been the very serious proposal to build an “ecological civilization,” with this commitment being solemnly written into the CCP’s constitution in 2012.
China’s situation reached a crisis when many analysts speculated that the nation’s economic gains were likely to be spent on increased health costs and productivity losses.
In asking what was the cause of these environmental problems, the standard answer has been that there is a failure in the rule of law, especially in environmental law. This was proposed as the most effective way to an ecological civilization: that environmental legislation and legal frameworks be strengthened.
However, the actual evidence has been that the effects of environmental law and regulation are very limited, even useless. Why is this? This is because environmental issues are not merely legal issues. They are social, political, cultural, and philosophical issues as well. The role of capital and of special interest groups is important, as well as the development model and the dominating anthropocentric worldview and values. Philosophically, both “ecological Marxism” and “constructive post-modernism” are regarded as philosophical resources for helping to create more generally an ecological civilization culturally and more practically for improving China’s environmental protection.
As difficult as it may be, China sees the need to change fundamentally the capitalist mode of production and way of life as essential for building an ecological civilization. Because China in a real sense had become addicted to economic growth, there is in the society intense resistance to an ecological civilization.
There does exist in China a one-dimensional development ideology of modernization under which the environment had become the political and social servant of capital’s logic of economic growth, which was expected to solve all important social problems.
This ideology was deeply embedded in the culture – for example, environmentalists protesting against a big dam project on the Nu River that was believed to be bringing serious harm to the local ecology was surprisingly voted for by the Indigenous residents who were eager for regional development and economic benefits.
Again, what can be called the anthropocentric worldview in modern China runs deep in the culture.
So, it is not enough to rely upon legislation and law to create an ecological civilization. Allies are needed, and an important intellectual and ideological ally is seen to be found in the influence that good philosophy can have upon culture. Among Chinese intellectuals, this particularly is found in ecological Marxism and what is known as “constructive post-modernism.”
For Chinese Marxists who believe the mission of philosophy is to change the world, ecological Marxism is held to be the Marxist solution for the capitalist ecological crisis. However, ecological Marxism has had to face up to the criticism and question that asks — if capitalism is the cause of ecological crisis, which is a central claim of ecological Marxism, then why does it seem to be more severe in socialist China?
This was a problem that Chinese scholars and analysts by 2013 began admitting and facing up to: that the ecological problems were definitely increasing in proportion with Chinese economic growth.
Constructive post-modernism has significant theoretical roots in the West and in the US in particular. It is based upon the process philosophy of A.N. Whitehead, who taught at both Cambridge and Harvard, and specifically promoted in China by Whitehead’s students, John Cobb and David Griffin of Claremont University in California.
It is a way of thinking that has caught the attention and imagination of many Chinese thinkers and is regarded as being able to articulate a pluralistic and yet integrative worldview and practice.
It is post-modern not in the sense of being anti-modern but in the sense of trying to build upon the best aspects of modernity and Chinese traditions, thus creating a new way of thinking that is more relational.
It is extraordinary how constructive postmodernism has taken root in Chinese higher education institutions. No other Western school of philosophy other than process philosophy and its constructive postmodernism has been found so attractive for China, neither analytic philosophy nor phenomenology, so influential in the West. It has largely been through the efforts of two American scholars, John Cobb and David Griffin, that this cross-fertilization has occurred, and the influence has not been limited only to the field of philosophy. Its reach has been transdisciplinary, and it has even guided the historical study of the Chinese Communist Party’s development.
Nevertheless, there still has been a spread of capitalist methods and values, the reality of coping with the ecological crisis, and the desire for building an ecological civilization.
Both Marxists and constructive post-modernists are seen as having important roles to play in improving laws and in building an ecological civilization.
These ways of thinking are understood in China as representing overlapping and, to a significant degree, complementary theoretical and ideological approaches, where Marxism, especially as articulated in what is called ecological Marxism, aids in thinking about meeting the ecological crisis in institutional and structural terms, whereas constructive postmodernism aids in reflecting on this crisis in cultural and spiritual ways.
It is acknowledged that ecological Marxism and constructive postmodernism, each as traditions of deep philosophical thought, have their own and differing emphases, and yet there is an overlap and even “fusion of horizons” in their respective contributions to this very real struggle in China to come to terms with the environmental crisis.
❝
Despite China’s deep mistrust, perhaps for good historical reasons, of the West’s expansionist economic development model, China has been open to certain elements in the West and, as we can see, has learned from Western intellectuals and scholars.
Ecological Marxism sees the ecological crisis as an epochal crisis much greater than the economic crisis because it threatens the long-term survival of both human and other life forms, and so it calls for an ecological revolution.
Constructive post-modernism also sees the ecological crisis as threatening civilization itself and in the very near future without the active pursuit of an alternative. Both philosophies are seen to awaken people to their historical-material reality.
And given China’s role as the biggest developing nation, with 20% of the world’s population, 9% of the arable land, and 6% of the fresh water, both forms of thinking and practice — ecological Marxism and constructive postmodernism – are aiding in emphasizing the need to give priority to people and their labor (in relation to capital) in carefully considering the issue of people’s livelihoods in making environmental decisions. There is no more mechanical imitation of Western development paths and environmental law.
Toward a fusion of horizons
Unfortunately, there are tremendous forces within the US urging for a New Cold War on China.
This is an almost inescapable reaction to China’s economic and technological rise, its pursuit of its own distinctive sovereign project, and what is said by many to be the accompanying end of US unipolar dominance in the world.
The US has pursued such an aggressive geopolitical course of dominance once before against both the Soviet Union and China after WWII.
Though the world survived this first Cold War, there are serious doubts about being able to survive a second one because of the grave economic and ecological consequences, along with the real risks for planetary life posed by thermonuclear war.
Clearly, despite China’s deep mistrust, perhaps for good historical reasons, of the West’s expansionist economic development model, China has been open to certain elements in the West and, as we can see, has learned from Western intellectuals and scholars.
The issue now becomes one of greater intercultural understanding on the basis of what has been called, by Hans Gadamer and Charles Taylor, a fusion of horizons.
This requires conversation, diplomacy, negotiation, and the mutual recognition between institutions, groups, and individuals of the genuine and complex intercultural challenges and opportunities that, at this historical juncture, China and the West present to one another.
This undoubtedly is also for the good of the world as a whole.
Nevertheless, there is a deep and serious epistemological issue here, and it requires the setting aside or surmounting of any lingering sense of American hegemonic exceptionalism.
Because one’s horizon designates the surrounding context within which everything we say and do has the sense and meaning that it does, we have to be prepared to acknowledge that other human beings belonging to other societies and cultures are also in contact with reality just as we are.
This means that the people of two different societies and cultures may very well understand their lives very differently and may have great difficulty in understanding one another, especially if they remain closed within certain schemas operating within their respective horizons.
However, neither oneself nor one’s interlocutor can ever be totally wrong and, most importantly, with committed conversation and diplomacy, horizons can be identified and distinguished on the basis of which we perhaps can grasp what is distorting understanding and impeding communication.
But also, these horizons evolve and change. They are not permanently fixed. They are something into which we move and which move with us.
A certain human “risk in openness” and what Gadamer and Taylor call “charity” is required.
Any position that firmly holds that, as a condition for one’s understanding of the other on their own terms of thinking and acting, one can only understand this other solely as making sense in one’s own terms, must be abandoned and overcome as a vestige of epistemological imperialism.
Such a fundamentally monological stance has a fatefully negative impact on any intercultural communications or diplomacy and, in this instance, perhaps even for our world’s survival.
Hope you loved reading this article. Global Catholic is powered by readers like you.
We have no corporate owner or funding agencies. Our in-depth commentaries, features and conversations are not behind the paywall.
We don’t carry advertisements as we want to offer a clutter-free reading experience.
To sustain and grow Global Catholic, we need to raise US$250,000.
As Pope Leo XIV journeyed through Uruguay, Argentina and Peru, the international press read three messages: the renewal of faith, the defense of democracy, and solidarity with the poor.
The midterm rebuke to Trumpism offers the Church a chance to free itself from ideological captivity, from the partisan entanglements that distorted its moral and social teaching.
Pope Leo XIV received Bob Dylan, an encounter rich with history, between a pope shaped by Augustine and the Bible, and a songwriter who has spoken Scripture for sixty years.
Trump’s midterm defeat raises an uncomfortable question: did Americans repudiate Trumpism or just high fuel prices, and what would it mean to truly “humanate,” to live by Christ’s selfless love?
The kerygma is God’s infinite love, and what truly attracts people to faith is not dogmatic orthodoxy but Christians who live that love toward the rejected and the suffering.
As tech companies turn to religion for moral guidance, the real question is not whether machines can gain a conscience, but whether humanity has conscience enough to govern artificial intelligence.
China and America in a burning world: A new philosophical-theological reflection
Google Search
Subscribe to Newsletter
In Europe this summer, there have been three heat waves unprecedented in their early onset, intensity, duration, and geographical expanse. The health impacts on humans, animals, and plants have been dramatic, exacerbating the impacts of inequality associated with housing, working conditions, transportation, and income.
In Canada, my own country, forest wildfires have been raging, requiring the evacuation of communities and exhausting firefighters and their resources. It is reported that in Ontario alone, by early summer, more land had been burned than in all of last year’s fires combined. Though many of the fires are in less populated areas, the air pollution from these fires reaches densely populated areas across North America, causing periods of apocalyptic gloom.
Edward Schillebeeckx OP has been widely noted to have been one of the most competent and courageous theologians able and willing to confront the creative, though often troublesome, tension between Christian doctrine and biblical scholarship.
Schillebeeckx once pointed out in his book Christ: The Experience of Jesus as Lord (1983) that the theology of the oppressed is not the theology of the converted … and that both have something important to say.
Whereas the dialogue partner of most Western European theology has been the unbeliever, as in the unbelieving humanist, the conversation partner of most non-Western theology has been the oppressed, the person held in subjection as the victim of our societal systems.
Schillebeeckx says it is precisely here that we have the modern problem of oppression for this present phase of the development of human consciousness. We are concerned about fellow human beings and the nature we all depend upon to live and that now suffers together an exploitation and oppression not only from other human beings, but more significantly from a socioeconomic and political system that now seemingly operates as an almost anonymous force that nonetheless is very real in its human and natural consequences.
The consequences now are such that previous distinctions between economic, social, ecological, and even spiritual or mental exploitation and oppression are tending to be less and less obvious.
Our dominant economic development model and practices increasingly are seen to be threatening more and more people’s actual living conditions and the natural conditions required for their just livelihood. This is a constant and mounting situation of oppression in our present circumstances that seems to make it impossible for the individual from the very outset to find the time or energy to become righteous.
This is not suffering for the Kingdom of God or for the good cause. It is simply dumb suffering. This, says Schillebeeckx, writing nearly 50 years ago, is or should be our new situation of theological awareness. It is very new in relation to what the Bible mostly says except in relation to the oldest Biblical story of the Hebrews’ lamentation over their slavery and an associated idolatry, which was what caused God to come and be among his people whether they be holy or not.
There are similar New Testament impulses, says Schillebeeckx, that have not yet fully emerged because of the Church’s self-focus rather than focusing on the prophet Jesus. The Church has tended to identify itself as the body of Christ, thereby failing to do justice to the real concerns of Ephesians and Colossians.
There is this new modern consciousness that rightly articulates itself in what has been called “human rights” of all, and not only of the good and just, not only of the members of the household of faith.
Schillebeeckx says that the New Testament rejects such a one-sidedness, asserting clearly that “the living God is the savior of all” as well as “of those who believe” (1 Tim. 4:10).
A political backlash against climate action
So now we have a global situation that is widely agreed to have been foreseeable and warned about in successive UN IPCC reports. The solutions also have been well known – that we must immediately and urgently reduce greenhouse gas emissions and phase out the use of fossil fuels as quickly as possible.
However, there has been in certain quarters and among certain well-endowed groups, particularly among the billionaire class, a significant rise in opposition to climate policies and environmental protection, and so investment in oil and natural gas continues.
It is reported that finance capital interests even increased their investment in fossil fuel development in 2024-2025. This backlash and backtracking by existing political leaders and governments on environmental protection have been led by forces in the US, where both denial and obscurantism have been intensified under Trump’s presidency.
Closer to home in Canada, for example, strikingly under Mark Carney’s new Liberal government, fossil fuel lobbyists have been able to meet with government officials an unprecedented 1,300 times during Carney’s first year in office, amounting to approximately five points of contact per working day.
Close observers and analysts now see a serious rift between the interests of capital and the interests of science.
This apparent ideological challenge is seen as also presenting a strategic opportunity to confront what now is looking very much like “state-sponsored criminality,” where even in certain instances recent court rulings are ignored and there seems to be a systematic and widespread readiness on the part of the ruling classes to sacrifice human civilization and the riches and beauty of nature for the sake of this economic system and its seemingly anonymous force and logic that Schillebeeckx reflected upon theologically not that long ago.
In France, many scientists, doctors, researchers, philosophers, and artists have called for a “climate emergency law” that would prevent companies from participating in any new fossil fuel projects — coal mines, gas fields, oil wells. It would also abolish all subsidies for fossil fuels.
❝
Though the world survived [the] first Cold War, there are serious doubts about being able to survive a second one because of the grave economic and ecological consequences, along with the real risks for planetary life posed by thermonuclear war.
China’s search for an ecological civilization
China also has had to face serious environmental issues. These problems increased with China’s ascendance as the world’s second-largest economy. And yet there has been the very serious proposal to build an “ecological civilization,” with this commitment being solemnly written into the CCP’s constitution in 2012.
China’s situation reached a crisis when many analysts speculated that the nation’s economic gains were likely to be spent on increased health costs and productivity losses.
In asking what was the cause of these environmental problems, the standard answer has been that there is a failure in the rule of law, especially in environmental law. This was proposed as the most effective way to an ecological civilization: that environmental legislation and legal frameworks be strengthened.
However, the actual evidence has been that the effects of environmental law and regulation are very limited, even useless. Why is this? This is because environmental issues are not merely legal issues. They are social, political, cultural, and philosophical issues as well. The role of capital and of special interest groups is important, as well as the development model and the dominating anthropocentric worldview and values. Philosophically, both “ecological Marxism” and “constructive post-modernism” are regarded as philosophical resources for helping to create more generally an ecological civilization culturally and more practically for improving China’s environmental protection.
As difficult as it may be, China sees the need to change fundamentally the capitalist mode of production and way of life as essential for building an ecological civilization. Because China in a real sense had become addicted to economic growth, there is in the society intense resistance to an ecological civilization.
There does exist in China a one-dimensional development ideology of modernization under which the environment had become the political and social servant of capital’s logic of economic growth, which was expected to solve all important social problems.
This ideology was deeply embedded in the culture – for example, environmentalists protesting against a big dam project on the Nu River that was believed to be bringing serious harm to the local ecology was surprisingly voted for by the Indigenous residents who were eager for regional development and economic benefits.
Again, what can be called the anthropocentric worldview in modern China runs deep in the culture.
So, it is not enough to rely upon legislation and law to create an ecological civilization. Allies are needed, and an important intellectual and ideological ally is seen to be found in the influence that good philosophy can have upon culture. Among Chinese intellectuals, this particularly is found in ecological Marxism and what is known as “constructive post-modernism.”
For Chinese Marxists who believe the mission of philosophy is to change the world, ecological Marxism is held to be the Marxist solution for the capitalist ecological crisis. However, ecological Marxism has had to face up to the criticism and question that asks — if capitalism is the cause of ecological crisis, which is a central claim of ecological Marxism, then why does it seem to be more severe in socialist China?
This was a problem that Chinese scholars and analysts by 2013 began admitting and facing up to: that the ecological problems were definitely increasing in proportion with Chinese economic growth.
Constructive post-modernism has significant theoretical roots in the West and in the US in particular. It is based upon the process philosophy of A.N. Whitehead, who taught at both Cambridge and Harvard, and specifically promoted in China by Whitehead’s students, John Cobb and David Griffin of Claremont University in California.
It is a way of thinking that has caught the attention and imagination of many Chinese thinkers and is regarded as being able to articulate a pluralistic and yet integrative worldview and practice.
It is post-modern not in the sense of being anti-modern but in the sense of trying to build upon the best aspects of modernity and Chinese traditions, thus creating a new way of thinking that is more relational.
It is extraordinary how constructive postmodernism has taken root in Chinese higher education institutions. No other Western school of philosophy other than process philosophy and its constructive postmodernism has been found so attractive for China, neither analytic philosophy nor phenomenology, so influential in the West. It has largely been through the efforts of two American scholars, John Cobb and David Griffin, that this cross-fertilization has occurred, and the influence has not been limited only to the field of philosophy. Its reach has been transdisciplinary, and it has even guided the historical study of the Chinese Communist Party’s development.
Nevertheless, there still has been a spread of capitalist methods and values, the reality of coping with the ecological crisis, and the desire for building an ecological civilization.
Both Marxists and constructive post-modernists are seen as having important roles to play in improving laws and in building an ecological civilization.
These ways of thinking are understood in China as representing overlapping and, to a significant degree, complementary theoretical and ideological approaches, where Marxism, especially as articulated in what is called ecological Marxism, aids in thinking about meeting the ecological crisis in institutional and structural terms, whereas constructive postmodernism aids in reflecting on this crisis in cultural and spiritual ways.
It is acknowledged that ecological Marxism and constructive postmodernism, each as traditions of deep philosophical thought, have their own and differing emphases, and yet there is an overlap and even “fusion of horizons” in their respective contributions to this very real struggle in China to come to terms with the environmental crisis.
❝
Despite China’s deep mistrust, perhaps for good historical reasons, of the West’s expansionist economic development model, China has been open to certain elements in the West and, as we can see, has learned from Western intellectuals and scholars.
Ecological Marxism sees the ecological crisis as an epochal crisis much greater than the economic crisis because it threatens the long-term survival of both human and other life forms, and so it calls for an ecological revolution.
Constructive post-modernism also sees the ecological crisis as threatening civilization itself and in the very near future without the active pursuit of an alternative. Both philosophies are seen to awaken people to their historical-material reality.
And given China’s role as the biggest developing nation, with 20% of the world’s population, 9% of the arable land, and 6% of the fresh water, both forms of thinking and practice — ecological Marxism and constructive postmodernism – are aiding in emphasizing the need to give priority to people and their labor (in relation to capital) in carefully considering the issue of people’s livelihoods in making environmental decisions. There is no more mechanical imitation of Western development paths and environmental law.
Toward a fusion of horizons
Unfortunately, there are tremendous forces within the US urging for a New Cold War on China.
This is an almost inescapable reaction to China’s economic and technological rise, its pursuit of its own distinctive sovereign project, and what is said by many to be the accompanying end of US unipolar dominance in the world.
The US has pursued such an aggressive geopolitical course of dominance once before against both the Soviet Union and China after WWII.
Though the world survived this first Cold War, there are serious doubts about being able to survive a second one because of the grave economic and ecological consequences, along with the real risks for planetary life posed by thermonuclear war.
Clearly, despite China’s deep mistrust, perhaps for good historical reasons, of the West’s expansionist economic development model, China has been open to certain elements in the West and, as we can see, has learned from Western intellectuals and scholars.
The issue now becomes one of greater intercultural understanding on the basis of what has been called, by Hans Gadamer and Charles Taylor, a fusion of horizons.
This requires conversation, diplomacy, negotiation, and the mutual recognition between institutions, groups, and individuals of the genuine and complex intercultural challenges and opportunities that, at this historical juncture, China and the West present to one another.
This undoubtedly is also for the good of the world as a whole.
Nevertheless, there is a deep and serious epistemological issue here, and it requires the setting aside or surmounting of any lingering sense of American hegemonic exceptionalism.
Because one’s horizon designates the surrounding context within which everything we say and do has the sense and meaning that it does, we have to be prepared to acknowledge that other human beings belonging to other societies and cultures are also in contact with reality just as we are.
This means that the people of two different societies and cultures may very well understand their lives very differently and may have great difficulty in understanding one another, especially if they remain closed within certain schemas operating within their respective horizons.
However, neither oneself nor one’s interlocutor can ever be totally wrong and, most importantly, with committed conversation and diplomacy, horizons can be identified and distinguished on the basis of which we perhaps can grasp what is distorting understanding and impeding communication.
But also, these horizons evolve and change. They are not permanently fixed. They are something into which we move and which move with us.
A certain human “risk in openness” and what Gadamer and Taylor call “charity” is required.
Any position that firmly holds that, as a condition for one’s understanding of the other on their own terms of thinking and acting, one can only understand this other solely as making sense in one’s own terms, must be abandoned and overcome as a vestige of epistemological imperialism.
Such a fundamentally monological stance has a fatefully negative impact on any intercultural communications or diplomacy and, in this instance, perhaps even for our world’s survival.
Hope you loved reading this article. Global Catholic is powered by readers like you.
We have no corporate owner or funding agencies. Our in-depth commentaries, features and conversations are not behind the paywall.
We don’t carry advertisements as we want to offer a clutter-free reading experience.
To sustain and grow Global Catholic, we need to raise US$250,000.
Join the remarkable Global Catholic journey
VATICAN DIARY
Leo in Latin America, as the international press saw him
SIGNS OF THE TIMES
US midterms: A liberating invitation for the US Church
WAYPOINTS
Bob Dylan and Pope Leo: two ‘Augustinians’
GRIMMGRAM
An election and ‘humanating’
LIGHTS AND SHADOWS
Love: Most authentic force of evangelization
MORALITY MATTERS
Can Artificial Intelligence have a conscience?
Latest
Stewardship and the dignity of every person
Cambridge’s 2026 word of the year is “human,” and so is Pope Leo’s encyclical
How Patriarch Kirill fused his office with his own personal power
Australia’s wave of job cuts forgets the human cost of work
AI might be eating what remains of your Catholic soul
Venite ad me: Why Vatican’s effort on faith transmission is moving at snail’s pace
Trending
Why the German Church still wrestles with its liturgical translations from Latin
Catholic Social Teaching and the non-person
Neither flight, nor flag: Benedict, Dominic and the Council
Council of Crete at 10: The unfinished work of Christian unity
AI might be eating what remains of your Catholic soul
Poverty: An indictment of society’s ethical crisis
Leo in Latin America, as the international press saw him
Stewardship and the dignity of every person
How Patriarch Kirill fused his office with his own personal power
The age of deference is over, even in the Church