Neither flight, nor flag: Benedict, Dominic and the Council
Pope Leo’s call to engage culture distinguishes condemned nationalism from honored patriotism, and that welcoming migrants is balanced by a nation’s right to order admissions.
At his general audience on Oct. 28, Pope Leo XIV read aloud a passage from Gaudium et Spes: “May the faithful, therefore, live in very close union with the other men of their time and may they strive to understand perfectly their way of thinking and judging, as expressed in their culture.” He framed it with a caution that faith is not to be lived in a spirit of opposition or hostility toward the world.
I welcome that catechesis without reservation, and for that reason I want to answer Father Antonio Spadaro’s recent commentary (Oct. 30, 2026 in Global Catholic), which read the Pope’s words as a rebuke aimed at “Christian nationalists” on one side and at Rod Dreher’s “Benedict Option” on the other.
Spadaro is right that Christianity worn as a badge of tribal belonging is not the faith of the Apostles. The Second Vatican Council itself taught that the Church is bound exclusively and indissolubly to no race or nation. Yet the commentary never defines its central term.
The Theos survey it cites measured a narrow question, chiefly whether one must be Christian to be truly British, and found that roughly one in nine respondents held that view.
St. John Paul II offered the distinction missing from the commentary: nationalism recognizes only the good of one’s own nation, while patriotism loves one’s homeland and respects the rights of others. The Church condemns the first. She has always honored the second.
St. Thomas places love of country under the virtue of piety, by which we render what we owe to our parents and our patria (Summa Theologiae II-II, q. 101, a. 1).
The Catechism teaches that love and service of one’s country follow from the duty of gratitude and belong to the order of charity (CCC 2239).
It is, therefore, a non sequitur to treat a cross carried beside a national flag as presumptive evidence of nationalism, still less of hostility toward migrants. That some marchers meant it so does not imply all did.
The cross on England’s flag belongs to St. George, a soldier-martyr from the eastern Mediterranean. A nation that adopts a foreigner as its patron has a patriotism that already points beyond itself.
What the Catechism actually teaches on migration
The commentary also omits half of the Pope’s teaching. Leo insisted that faith enriches and fulfills every culture it encounters and “is itself called to become a culture that is shaped by Christ.”
Read Benedict XVI’s hermeneutic of continuity, which calls for conversion, not accommodation. The same selectivity marks much commentary on immigration.
Paragraph 2241 of the Catechism has three movements: more prosperous nations are obliged to welcome the foreigner “to the extent they are able”; political authorities may subject the right to immigrate to “various juridical conditions”; and immigrants are obliged to respect their new country’s heritage, obey its laws, and share its burdens.
The Holy Father holds all three. He has said plainly that every country has the right to determine who enters, how, and when, while insisting that migrants be treated as human beings. Migration is not a sentimental journey without duties as well as rights.
“To the extent they are able” is not a pious formula. It calls for a prudential judgment about capacity, and capacity is measured in part by public money.
The Congressional Budget Office reports that the United States closed fiscal year 2026 with a deficit of $2.0 trillion, and the Government Accountability Office estimates that federal agencies made about $186 billion in improper payments, including fraud, in a single year. Research shows that immigration’s fiscal effects depend heavily on the route of entry, age, and skill.
The National Academies found that first-generation immigrants cost state and local governments more than the native-born, though their children become strong contributors; a major Dutch study found that labor migrants were net contributors, while family and asylum routes imposed substantial net costs.
A nation that weighs such facts and orders its admissions accordingly is not indulging in nationalism or racism. It is exercising the stewardship the Catechism assigns to political authority without diminishing the migrant’s dignity.
A Benedict option, and a Dominic option
The commentary also numbers the Benedict Option among the ways of setting oneself against the world. That misreads both the saint and the proposal. Benedict did leave the schools of Rome, but what he founded became the seedbed of a civilization.
In 2008, Benedict XVI made the point at the Collège des Bernardins: the monks did not set out to build a culture; they set out to seek God, quaerere Deum. Because God had spoken in a Word, that search required the infrastructure of study: books and schools. What we call Western Civilization grew from that seed.
As a Lay Dominican, I will add its complement: a Dominic option.
In 1217 St. Dominic scattered his young Order, sending his friars two by two to Paris, Bologna, and Spain, and beyond, where the culture of the age was being made.
St. Thomas Aquinas read Aristotle, and others, so seriously that each article of the Summa opens by stating the opposing view. That is the Council’s “strive to understand perfectly,” practiced seven centuries early.
Benedict and Dominic are not rivals. Stability without mission becomes a museum; mission without stability becomes a voice with nothing to say.
It is fitting that this catechesis comes from a son of St. Augustine. The City of God teaches that the two cities are intermingled until the end of time and that the pilgrim city makes use of earthly peace while knowing that its true citizenship lies elsewhere.
That is neither flight nor flag worship. It is the posture that Gaudium et Spes asks of us and that the Holy Father commends: closer union with the people of our time, so that the Gospel may once again form our culture in Christ.
John C. Keenan is an attorney in Boise, Idaho, and President of the Lay Provincial Council of the Western Dominican Province (Province of the Most Holy Name of Jesus).
Hope you loved reading this article. Global Catholic is powered by readers like you.
We have no corporate owner or funding agencies. Our in-depth commentaries, features and conversations are not behind the paywall.
We don’t carry advertisements as we want to offer a clutter-free reading experience.
To sustain and grow Global Catholic, we need to raise US$250,000.
Having retraced Francis’s legacy from Uruguay to Argentina, Leo casts his South American journey as traveling in reverse the road his predecessor once walked.
The midterm rebuke to Trumpism offers the Church a chance to free itself from ideological captivity, from the partisan entanglements that distorted its moral and social teaching.
Pope Leo XIV received Bob Dylan, an encounter rich with history, between a pope shaped by Augustine and the Bible, and a songwriter who has spoken Scripture for sixty years.
Trump’s midterm defeat raises an uncomfortable question: did Americans repudiate Trumpism or just high fuel prices, and what would it mean to truly “humanate,” to live by Christ’s selfless love?
The kerygma is God’s infinite love, and what truly attracts people to faith is not dogmatic orthodoxy but Christians who live that love toward the rejected and the suffering.
As tech companies turn to religion for moral guidance, the real question is not whether machines can gain a conscience, but whether humanity has conscience enough to govern artificial intelligence.
Neither flight, nor flag: Benedict, Dominic and the Council
Google Search
Subscribe to Newsletter
At his general audience on Oct. 28, Pope Leo XIV read aloud a passage from Gaudium et Spes: “May the faithful, therefore, live in very close union with the other men of their time and may they strive to understand perfectly their way of thinking and judging, as expressed in their culture.” He framed it with a caution that faith is not to be lived in a spirit of opposition or hostility toward the world.
I welcome that catechesis without reservation, and for that reason I want to answer Father Antonio Spadaro’s recent commentary (Oct. 30, 2026 in Global Catholic), which read the Pope’s words as a rebuke aimed at “Christian nationalists” on one side and at Rod Dreher’s “Benedict Option” on the other.
Spadaro is right that Christianity worn as a badge of tribal belonging is not the faith of the Apostles. The Second Vatican Council itself taught that the Church is bound exclusively and indissolubly to no race or nation. Yet the commentary never defines its central term.
The Theos survey it cites measured a narrow question, chiefly whether one must be Christian to be truly British, and found that roughly one in nine respondents held that view.
St. John Paul II offered the distinction missing from the commentary: nationalism recognizes only the good of one’s own nation, while patriotism loves one’s homeland and respects the rights of others. The Church condemns the first. She has always honored the second.
St. Thomas places love of country under the virtue of piety, by which we render what we owe to our parents and our patria (Summa Theologiae II-II, q. 101, a. 1).
The Catechism teaches that love and service of one’s country follow from the duty of gratitude and belong to the order of charity (CCC 2239).
It is, therefore, a non sequitur to treat a cross carried beside a national flag as presumptive evidence of nationalism, still less of hostility toward migrants. That some marchers meant it so does not imply all did.
The cross on England’s flag belongs to St. George, a soldier-martyr from the eastern Mediterranean. A nation that adopts a foreigner as its patron has a patriotism that already points beyond itself.
What the Catechism actually teaches on migration
The commentary also omits half of the Pope’s teaching. Leo insisted that faith enriches and fulfills every culture it encounters and “is itself called to become a culture that is shaped by Christ.”
Read Benedict XVI’s hermeneutic of continuity, which calls for conversion, not accommodation. The same selectivity marks much commentary on immigration.
Paragraph 2241 of the Catechism has three movements: more prosperous nations are obliged to welcome the foreigner “to the extent they are able”; political authorities may subject the right to immigrate to “various juridical conditions”; and immigrants are obliged to respect their new country’s heritage, obey its laws, and share its burdens.
The Holy Father holds all three. He has said plainly that every country has the right to determine who enters, how, and when, while insisting that migrants be treated as human beings. Migration is not a sentimental journey without duties as well as rights.
“To the extent they are able” is not a pious formula. It calls for a prudential judgment about capacity, and capacity is measured in part by public money.
The Congressional Budget Office reports that the United States closed fiscal year 2026 with a deficit of $2.0 trillion, and the Government Accountability Office estimates that federal agencies made about $186 billion in improper payments, including fraud, in a single year. Research shows that immigration’s fiscal effects depend heavily on the route of entry, age, and skill.
The National Academies found that first-generation immigrants cost state and local governments more than the native-born, though their children become strong contributors; a major Dutch study found that labor migrants were net contributors, while family and asylum routes imposed substantial net costs.
A nation that weighs such facts and orders its admissions accordingly is not indulging in nationalism or racism. It is exercising the stewardship the Catechism assigns to political authority without diminishing the migrant’s dignity.
A Benedict option, and a Dominic option
The commentary also numbers the Benedict Option among the ways of setting oneself against the world. That misreads both the saint and the proposal. Benedict did leave the schools of Rome, but what he founded became the seedbed of a civilization.
In 2008, Benedict XVI made the point at the Collège des Bernardins: the monks did not set out to build a culture; they set out to seek God, quaerere Deum. Because God had spoken in a Word, that search required the infrastructure of study: books and schools. What we call Western Civilization grew from that seed.
As a Lay Dominican, I will add its complement: a Dominic option.
In 1217 St. Dominic scattered his young Order, sending his friars two by two to Paris, Bologna, and Spain, and beyond, where the culture of the age was being made.
St. Thomas Aquinas read Aristotle, and others, so seriously that each article of the Summa opens by stating the opposing view. That is the Council’s “strive to understand perfectly,” practiced seven centuries early.
Benedict and Dominic are not rivals. Stability without mission becomes a museum; mission without stability becomes a voice with nothing to say.
It is fitting that this catechesis comes from a son of St. Augustine. The City of God teaches that the two cities are intermingled until the end of time and that the pilgrim city makes use of earthly peace while knowing that its true citizenship lies elsewhere.
That is neither flight nor flag worship. It is the posture that Gaudium et Spes asks of us and that the Holy Father commends: closer union with the people of our time, so that the Gospel may once again form our culture in Christ.
John C. Keenan is an attorney in Boise, Idaho, and President of the Lay Provincial Council of the Western Dominican Province (Province of the Most Holy Name of Jesus).
Hope you loved reading this article. Global Catholic is powered by readers like you.
We have no corporate owner or funding agencies. Our in-depth commentaries, features and conversations are not behind the paywall.
We don’t carry advertisements as we want to offer a clutter-free reading experience.
To sustain and grow Global Catholic, we need to raise US$250,000.
Join the remarkable Global Catholic journey
VATICAN DIARY
Leo carries Francis’ legacy through Latin America
SIGNS OF THE TIMES
US midterms: A liberating invitation for the US Church
WAYPOINTS
Bob Dylan and Pope Leo: two ‘Augustinians’
GRIMMGRAM
An election and ‘humanating’
LIGHTS AND SHADOWS
Love: Most authentic force of evangelization
MORALITY MATTERS
Can Artificial Intelligence have a conscience?
Latest
The US cannot bomb Iran into submission, but must negotiate with it
What if Trump isn’t denying climate change, but planning for it?
When the comedian who made us laugh turns out to be AI
Why Pope Leo XIV’s honesty about his health matters
Neither flight, nor flag: Benedict, Dominic and the Council
Can Artificial Intelligence have a conscience?
Trending
US midterms: A liberating invitation for the US Church
Theology for a Synodal Church: Vatican II’s unfinished legacy
Leo carries Francis’ legacy through Latin America
Can Artificial Intelligence have a conscience?
Meet the Kenyan sister breaking the silence on abuse of nuns
Mega Anthropic IPO: Should Christians invest?
Homophobia and misogyny in the Church share one root, argues Spanish theologian
From spy chief to Vatican envoy: Germany’s ambassador on Pope Leo
America rejected Trump, yet he governs on: what happens now?
Should the Church still speak of ‘heresy’?