Ed Sheeran and the collapse of the apolitical pop star

The Sheeran-Macklemore concert controversy shows that at the scale of fame, political neutrality collapses, and the real question is whether an artist’s political speech is informed, honest and owned.
Sheeran at the Queen Elizabeth II Platinum Jubilee 2022 - Platinum Pageant, outside Buckingham Palace. (Photo: Wikipedia)
Sheeran at the Queen Elizabeth II Platinum Jubilee 2022 – Platinum Pageant, outside Buckingham Palace. (Photo: Wikipedia)

Subscribe to Newsletter

    For fifteen years, Ed Sheeran has built a career on songs of ordinary feeling: first love, family, a castle on a hill in Suffolk. He has cultivated the persona of the everyman with a guitar, and part of that persona has been a studied distance from politics.

    On Sept. 19, at Lincoln Financial Field in Philadelphia, Sheeran opened his show without a support act, without a backing band, and in tears. He told the crowd that the Oct. 7 attack at the Nova music festival was horrific, and that what is happening to civilians in Gaza is catastrophic, unjustifiable and disproportionate.

    He apologized for the decisions of the previous week, saying, “I’ve had to take and make difficult decisions, and I am making mistakes, and I’m so, so sorry.” He added that he had “never wanted to be an activist musician,” but that the situation had put him “in the middle of an important and passionate argument about freedom of speech and the most complex political issue on the planet.”

    Outside the stadium, around fifty pro-Palestinian demonstrators had gathered, waving flags and chanting.

    A month earlier, Sheeran had one of the most bankable and least political brands in popular music. The collapse of that neutrality over a single week raises questions about artists who speak out on politically divisive issues. If there was once a question of whether artists should sacrifice bankable neutrality, it is now a question of how they do so.

    When advocacy is built into the act

    On the North American leg of Sheeran’s Loop world tour, his support act, the singer-songwriter Macklemore (Ben Haggerty), opened at MetLife Stadium in New Jersey. He came on wearing a keffiyeh and addressed the audience: “One of the reasons why I wanted to come on this tour was because I wanted to stand up here on stages and stadiums across America and say two words that are very near and dear to my heart: Free Palestine. I said, Free Palestine! I want those words to be loud and clear, so the people from Gaza all the way to the occupied West Bank know that we have not forgotten them.”

    He accused Israel of apartheid and genocide, then performed the protest song “Hind’s Hall” while footage of Gaza and of pro-Palestinian demonstrations played on the screens behind him.

    He named other countries in various stages of crisis, among them Lebanon, Cuba, Congo and Sudan, and described the US immigration enforcement agency ICE as a terrorist organization. He repeated the set the following night.

    Political activism is not an intrusion into Macklemore’s act but a deliberate feature of it. He wrote “Hind’s Hall” in 2024 in support of the campus protest encampments across the United States, naming it for the Columbia students who had renamed Hamilton Hall after Hind Rajab, a five-year-old killed in Gaza.

    At a Washington rally in November 2023, he told the crowd that the Gaza war, then four weeks old, was a genocide, and he had made similar comments in a lengthy Instagram post the previous month, on Oct. 19. Any promoter booking Macklemore for a stadium tour in 2026 was booking all of that.

    As a result of all this, many have asked whether entertainers with large audiences should be political, but the more useful question is what makes their political speech worth hearing, and whether their public stance comes from knowledge and commitment, or from the pressures of the industry or their audience.

    Stadium owners then contacted Sheeran. According to The Wall Street Journal, Robert Kraft spoke with him in a phone call of roughly forty minutes, explaining that Macklemore could not perform in their venues if he stayed on the bill.

    Kraft cited the rapper’s onstage comments, in particular the framing of Israel as committing genocide and a selective presentation that omitted Hamas’s role, as hate speech rather than protected free speech.

    What turned a dispute into a crisis was in large part the mechanism of its delivery.

    On Instagram, Macklemore said that Sheeran had told him Kraft rallied the other stadium owners, who collectively issued an ultimatum: if the rapper stayed on the bill, Sheeran would not play their venues. Macklemore was dropped from the remaining US dates.

    Told briefly, the episode flattens into a simple story of a powerful owner silencing an artist, a version that readily produces outrage and cries of censorship.

    Treating it as a generic exercise of commercial power sets aside its particular history, the substance of Kraft’s objections, and the place Macklemore’s advocacy already held in the act, which was integral rather than incidental.

    The owner of the stage

    Robert Kraft, the Jewish owner of the New England Patriots and Gillette Stadium in Massachusetts, founded the Foundation to Combat Antisemitism, now the Blue Square Alliance Against Hate, an organization that monitors online hatred from offices beside the stadium.

    Kraft said the stadium does not provide a “platform for hate speech,” and that Macklemore’s participation in the September concerts would cross that line, citing his recent actions and the material shared from the stage in New Jersey as “deeply offensive and hurtful.”

    That material was a video accompanying the set which depicted Israeli soldiers as Nazis. Jewish concertgoers at MetLife complained about it, and groups of Jews and Israelis left their seats in protest.

    In the same call, Kraft referred to Macklemore’s “broader history of antisemitic rhetoric and imagery,” pointing to a 2014 incident in which Macklemore played a surprise set at Seattle’s Museum of Pop Culture, taking the stage to sing “Thrift Shop” in an oversized prosthetic hooked nose, bowl-cut wig, dark beard and black suit.

    Critics at the time, among them the actor Seth Rogen, called it an antisemitic caricature. Macklemore first described it as a ‘random costume’ and later apologized, acknowledging that in the context of stereotyping it could be read as a Jewish caricature.

    Kraft’s statement was not a blanket rejection of Palestinian advocacy. In it, the 85-year-old said his decision ‘is not about diminishing the suffering of innocent Palestinians or denying anyone the right to advocate on their behalf’:

    “Their pain and loss are real. But that advocacy should not come at the expense of the Jewish community or obscure the responsibility of Hamas, a United States and globally designated terrorist organization whose horrific actions have caused immeasurable suffering for Palestinians and Israelis alike.”

    “I agree with Macklemore. Too many lives have been lost and there has been too much suffering, but only sharing selective information and ignoring the actions of Hamas is not honest and only advances more divisiveness and hate. Over many decades, I have directed resources to Palestine and created athletic and entrepreneurial opportunities for Palestinians who I admire and respect. Standing with the Palestinian people and standing against Hamas, antisemitism and hate should not be mutually exclusive.”

    Kraft’s charge against the entertainer was one of distortion, and he offered to sit down with Macklemore to discuss it.

    What makes political speech worth hearing

    Much of the conversation around this has been framed in terms of free speech, which is an awkward fit. No government acted. The owners of the few dozen venues large enough to hold a stadium tour decided what could be said from their stages, and one of them had the standing to coordinate the others.

    Sheeran posted his first response on Instagram the day after Macklemore publicly announced his removal from the Loop Tour, explaining that his audiences did not come expecting a political forum.

    His remaining support acts then withdrew in solidarity with Macklemore. Finneas said artists must not be silenced when they speak up for the oppressed, and Lukas Graham, Aaron Rowe and Sheeran’s backing band Beoga followed on the same grounds.

    Palestinian advocacy groups around the world extended a boycott call to Sheeran’s entire world tour, and ticket holders returned tickets in support of Macklemore. One of them, protesting outside the Philadelphia stadium, argued that Sheeran’s choice not to take a stand was itself a political choice.

    Within 48 hours of Macklemore’s removal, between Sept. 14 and 16, Sheeran lost roughly 150,000 to 200,000 followers on Instagram. By Sept. 23, the loss was approaching half a million, taking him from around 47.7 million to approximately 47.2 million. Macklemore gained more than 1.5 million followers over the same period.

    Resale ticket prices fell sharply on the secondary market. For the Philadelphia show on 19 September, the cheapest available tickets dropped by roughly 45 to 50 percent in the days before the concert, from the US$100 to $126 range to as low as $37 or $51. Across nine of the ten remaining US dates, resale prices declined by up to 45 percent.

    A week later, in Philadelphia, Macklemore announced a tour of his own, with proceeds going to organizations supporting Palestinians.

    Citing severe weather warnings, Sheeran’s promoters cancelled his two scheduled shows at Robert Kraft’s Gillette Stadium in Foxborough, Massachusetts, on Sept. 25 and 26, with ticket holders offered refunds. As of writing, the Loop tour is scheduled to resume in Atlanta on Oct. 3, with a new backing band and no named support acts.

    Sheeran now stands where the politically-neutral artist who tries to please everyone tends to end up – accused by free-speech advocates of yielding to venue censorship, criticized by pro-Palestinian advocates for speaking too late, and challenged by supporters of Israel who regard his moral weighting as incomplete and misleading.

    It may be that Sheeran’s original position of political neutrality or disengagement no longer exists at this scale. His silence was first read as consent to Macklemore’s removal, and his statement, when it came, was read as capitulation or as too late.

    The episode sets a floor for public figures more generally where at a certain level of visibility, declining to hold any position is itself a position, and others will assign it a charged meaning.

    When he announced his new solo Free Palestine tour on Instagram, Macklemore framed the controversy this way: “When the billionaire class can decide which voices are allowed on stage and which ones are too dangerous to hear, everyone should be paying attention.”

    Yet the stage has always had owners who determined which voices would be heard, and has never been free from contests of influence. Shakespeare’s history plays argue the legitimacy of the dynasty under whose protection his company worked, and the boundaries around what could be staged were real.

    The modern patron differs in one important respect. Kraft published his reasons and defended them, and Macklemore had a global platform on which to dispute them the same afternoon. The argument about who may speak now happens, perhaps appropriately, in public, which is an improvement on the Privy Council.

    Kraft’s criticism that Macklemore selectively presented only part of the issue raises another question about how faithfully political art should represent the facts. All art is selective, and no work can tell the whole story. What matters is whether those choices help us understand an issue or distort it.

    In the Sheeran and Macklemore controversy, that is the line the two men are arguing about. Footage that renders Israeli soldiers as Nazis makes a contested claim about who those people are, and it invites the response it received. Saying ‘Free Palestine’ from a stadium stage is, from most angles, an innocuous thing; lumping Israelis and Nazis together does no service to anyone’s argument.

    The weight of an artist’s political views should be commensurate with how well they understand the issue. The risk, particularly with a distant and ongoing conflict, is speaking with more certainty than their knowledge justifies. Macklemore’s account of the war reflects a view widely shared among politically active celebrities, but reduces a complex conflict to a simple moral drama.

    Still, Macklemore has been consistent in his position for years, and his willingness to acknowledge that others know more about the conflict gives his advocacy credibility.

    Sheeran, on the other hand, found himself in the awkward position of a singer-songwriter saying he was working out how to contribute to a conversation while listening and learning “because I do not know enough.”

    The traditional calculation for entertainers has been that politics framed as universal humanity is commercially safer than specific political loyalties.

    The Macklemore episode complicates that, because at a certain level of visibility declining to declare a position now seems to carry its own penalty. It is reasonable to ask how much of the middle ground Sheeran has lost, when in his case the middle ground was the whole commercial proposition.

    As a result of all this, many have asked whether entertainers with large audiences should be political at all, but the more useful question ask what is it that makes their political speech worth hearing, and does their public stance comes from knowledge and commitment, or from the pressures of the industry or their audience?

    There’s also a consideration of whether the artist is candid about the limits of their own views, and selectivity of focus and similarly, if those who own the stage do put pressure on billed acts to meet certain expectations, whether they do so in the open.

    By that measure, each party has something to its credit here. Kraft published his reasons and offered to meet. Macklemore has said the same thing for three years and accepted the consequences. Sheeran arrived late, and said he does not know enough, which has the merit of being true.

    It’s clear that artists have no duty to become commentators on every crisis, and no right to assume that their fame confers upon them any particular measure of wisdom. And yet we should expect that political statements from the stage will become more common.

    What matters then is whether the artist knows what he or she is saying, acknowledges the limits of their knowledge, and accepts responsibility for turning a stage into a political platform.

    Perhaps what this episode illustrates most clearly is that when it comes to the most divisive global political issues, there may be shrinking ground for artists with large audiences who would rather opt for a silent political neutrality.

    This column first appeared in Eureka Street and is republished by Global Catholic with permission.

    Hope you loved reading this article. Global Catholic is powered by readers like you.

    We have no corporate owner or funding agencies. Our in-depth commentaries, features and conversations are not behind the paywall.

    We don’t carry advertisements as we want to offer a clutter-free reading experience.

    To sustain and grow Global Catholic, we need to raise US$250,000.

    Join the remarkable Global Catholic journey

    Share your comments

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    Pope Leo XIV welcomes Bob Dylan (third left) at the Vatican City alongside Fr. Antonio Spadaro (left). (Photo supplied)

    Bob Dylan and Pope Leo: two ‘Augustinians’

    Pope Leo XIV received Bob Dylan, an encounter rich with history, between a pope shaped by Augustine and the Bible, and a songwriter who has spoken Scripture for sixty years.
    Former US President Barack Obama (center) stands on stage with Democratic candidates Abdul El-Sayed (left) and Jocelyn Benson at a campaign rally in Detroit, Michigan. (Photo: Facebook/Democrats)

    An election and ‘humanating’

    Trump’s midterm defeat raises an uncomfortable question: did Americans repudiate Trumpism or just high fuel prices, and what would it mean to truly “humanate,” to live by Christ’s selfless love?
    A Christian man engaged in street ministry is seen holding a placard with a bible verse on God's love. (Photo: Pexels)

    Love: Most authentic force of evangelization

    The kerygma is God’s infinite love, and what truly attracts people to faith is not dogmatic orthodoxy but Christians who live that love toward the rejected and the suffering.
    Join the remarkable Global Catholic journey

    Join the remarkable Global Catholic journey

    Global Catholic is proud to be independent—editorially, politically, ideologically and financially.

    But independence comes at a cost. Without patron support, we depend entirely on readers and friends like you.

    To sustain and grow Global Catholic, we need to raise US$250,000.