Your social media profile is slowly consuming the real you

Virtual profiles feed on real time and energy until their creators, like Gógol’s overcoat or the film “The Substance,” are hollowed out by them.
Theatrical poster of 'The Substance' movie starring Demi Moore. (Photo : Wikipedia)
Theatrical poster of ‘The Substance’ movie starring Demi Moore. (Photo : Wikipedia)

Subscribe to Newsletter

    When we create a social media profile, we detach from our own reality and give life to another being that derives from us. We create a virtual “self.” This self, whose humanity disappeared somewhere in the crossing between the real and the virtual, must now be managed, administered.

    Reducing the “I” to its own idea of itself leads to psychic illness, which can ultimately end in the “I”’s own destruction at the hands of technology.

    A derivative being is gestated: a second body that demands nourishment and energy for its existence, like a foreign body lodging itself in the human psyche.

    The fragmentation produced by social media is like a tumor. It devours the vital tissue of the real self with the corrosive energy of the ideal self.

    In most analyses of social media use, we worry almost exclusively about wasted time and exposure to useless content. That concern is simple enough in its cause. But its limits run up against the narrowness of the claim itself. It’s clear that time spent on social media can drastically reduce the texture of a person’s lived experience.

    But I’d suggest the graver problem isn’t time alone — it’s the vital energy spent administering this being that derives from us.

    The conversation shifts, then, away from the common-sense question of whether social media is “useful,” and into another dimension entirely: the question of being itself. It isn’t the use of the network that matters most, but human subjectivity itself, shaped by the network and through it.

    The logic of sacrifice becomes evident. The real body is sacrificed as the vital substance of existence so that the virtual one can emerge.

    You are fragmented into two. Mismanaging your virtual “self” will generate serious consequences for your real one — consequences ranging from the destruction of your image and self-esteem to, in extreme cases, incitement to public lynching and suicide.

    The logic of sacrifice isn’t confined to the individual. It reaches the collective plane, too. Political participation in public space is hollowed out. If we are creating virtual individuals, we are, by extension, generating virtual societies.

    Political contest shifts from the real plane to the virtual one, ultimately captured by a handful of American billionaires who administer the virtual public square as they please. Yes, this politics isn’t real — it’s a simulacrum, and in the simulacrum, what matters is the law of spectacle among virtual spectators.

    The simulacrum, though, doesn’t stay confined to screens.

    A woman was once beaten to death after false rumors spread that she was a witch. From the virtual to the real, the consequence for that woman was a brutal lynching and death. The real could no longer overpower the virtual. Her screams were real, but the crowd’s rage was commanded by a virtual entity. The alleged witch died.

    In 2014, Fabiane Maria de Jesus, a Brazilian housewife, was beaten to death in Guarujá, São Paulo state, after a Facebook page falsely identified her as a child kidnapper performing witchcraft rituals,as documented by Global Voices and Brazilian outlets covering the case.

    Episodes like this become possible because social media has platformed and standardized our experience of life, our existence through consumption, our behavior in the virtual world. And like any homogeneous organism, a lack of difference makes us extremely vulnerable to any foreign body capable of exterminating us far more quickly and efficiently.

    Virtual bodies, predictable and tamed by the administration of the mass algorithm.

    “The Substance”: the split between the real and the ideal

    Few recent works have given such literal shape to this duplication as The Substance (2024), by French director Coralie Fargeat — the film won the Best Screenplay award at the 2024 Cannes Film Festival.

    The film tells the story of Elisabeth Sparkle (played by Demi Moore), a television star who, on turning fifty, is discarded by the producer of the fitness show she hosts. Desperate, she agrees to inject a black-market substance that promises to generate a “better” version of herself.

    Out of her own body, tearing through her back, is born Sue (played by Margaret Qualley) — young, perfect, desirable. The rules are simple and non-negotiable. Elisabeth is the matrix. The two must alternate existence every seven days, without exception. And a warning repeats like a mantra throughout the film: remember, you are one.

    The virtual being is born from us, and feeds on us. While Sue lives, Elisabeth remains inert, hooked to a feeding tube. The existence of one depends on the erasure of the other. The two cannot be awake at the same time.

    The drama begins when Sue decides seven days aren’t enough. She steals time from the matrix. She extracts more fluid, prolongs her time in the spotlight, and each stolen day exacts its price on Elisabeth’s body, which ages in a grotesque, accelerated way.

    First a finger rots, then the hand, then the face. The simulacrum grows at the expense of real tissue. This is the most precise image of what I’ve called a tumor. The ideal self, devours the real self, and does so with the real self’s own consent — a self that can no longer live without the version it created.

    What’s most striking in the film is that Elisabeth, even though she could stop the process, doesn’t. She hates Sue and, at the same time, needs her.

    In one of the most painful scenes, she gets ready to meet an old schoolmate who admired her exactly as she was. In front of the mirror, she retouches her makeup so many times that she eventually gives up on the date altogether.

    The real gaze of someone who desired her wasn’t enough to compete with the imagined gaze of the public. How many of us do the same thing, refusing a real encounter because we can’t bear the distance between who we are and what we post?

    The real body lies stretched out, naked, on the cold bathroom tile. The simulacrum goes out, dances, travels the world, goes to concerts, consumes, takes selfies, buys this year’s car, buys the two-story house, exercises at 5 a.m., works until midnight, produces, produces, produces.

    The frenzied pace never stops. It laughs, goes out with friends, walks the dog, takes more photos, buys more clothes, consumes, eats, sleeps with more people, discards more people, kisses more people, makes more friends, speaks more languages, does yoga, meditates, falls asleep faster, sleeps less, sleeps more, takes more medication — medication to sleep, medication to wake up, medication to work out, medication to have sex, medication to laugh, medication to rest, medication to have fun, medication to post, posts the medication, posts the laughter, posts the tears, posts the joy, posts the sorrow, posts the movie, posts the house, posts the existence, posts the post about another post.

    Posts the birth, posts the death, posts the illness, posts the cat, the dog, the parrot, the suicide attempt, the recovery in the ward, posts the fall. Posts the text, the review. Posts.

    The simulacrum blends with the real, the real becomes part of the simulacrum, and we no longer know which is which, who is who. What’s real and what’s virtual? Does the real feed the virtual, or does the virtual now feed the real? Are our decisions based on the algorithms?

    In the film, the answer arrives in the form of a monster. From the final dose emerges a shapeless creature, the Elisasue Monster — a collage of bodies that no longer knows which of them is the matrix.

    Even so, it insists on going on stage for the New Year’s special. It puts on an earring and glues an old photo of Elisabeth’s face over its deformed one, like applying a filter. The audience that had cheered Sue now screams in horror and turns on her.

    The same public that consumed the image is the one that lynches it when the image fails. The witch dies again. What’s left of that body crawls to Elisabeth’s star on the Hollywood Walk of Fame and dissolves there, a stain that a street-cleaning machine sweeps up the next morning.

    The subject’s death is no longer even an event. It’s residue to be removed so the show can go on.

    Elisabeth’s body isn’t the only one lying on that bathroom floor. We are easy, defenseless prey, because our governments’ own regulatory capacity has likewise been reduced and subordinated by virtual political lynching. There are profiles for our government institutions on social media, just as there are for presidents, representatives, ministers and senators.

    The republic is fragmented between the real and the virtual, and it, too, has produced its own Sue.

    The lawmaker who legislates for the video clip, the minister who governs by engagement metrics, the institution that fears backlash more than injustice. While the simulacrum of the republic dances on-screen, its real body — made of schools, hospitals, courts and streets — lies on the cold bathroom floor, fed by a tube.

    And we are not the ones holding the syringe. In the film, the company that sells the substance never appears. There’s only a phone number, a voice, and a cabinet from which the boxes are retrieved. The supplier is invisible. The addiction isn’t.

    “The Overcoat”: external validation as a condition for existence

    If The Substance shows what happens to the body that feeds the simulacrum, what’s left to understand is why we agree to feed it in the first place. For that, it’s worth going back to 1842, when Nikolai Gogol published The Overcoat, which tells the story of Akaky Akakievich, a minor clerk in a St. Petersburg government office whose entire life consisted of copying documents.

    He didn’t draft, didn’t create, didn’t decide. He copied. And he found in that copying a kind of silent pleasure. When he was once offered a slightly more complex task — changing a document’s title and converting a few verbs from first person to third — Akaky broke into a sweat, grew anxious, and asked to go back to copying.

    It’s no accident that copying is the quintessential activity of social media. Reposting, reproducing the trend, repeating the fashionable audio clip, the dance of the moment, the opinion of the day. The platformed subject is a copyist who can no longer bear the task of altering his own verbs. That’s precisely why he’s so predictable, and so easy to manage.

    Akaky’s old overcoat was so worn out that his colleagues mocked him, calling it a housecoat. The tailor Petrovich tells him there’s no fixing it — he needs a new one. Akaky then reorganizes his entire life around this object.

    He stops drinking tea in the evening, stops lighting candles, starts walking on tiptoe to spare his shoe soles. Gogol tells us the idea of the overcoat began to accompany him like a companion, as if he had gotten married. A man’s entire existence comes to revolve around a wrapping.

    When he finally puts on the new overcoat, something changes. His colleagues, who had ignored him until then, greet him, compliment him, and throw a party in his honor. For the first time, Akaky exists in the eyes of others.

    But it wasn’t Akaky who came to exist — it was the overcoat. It’s the object that receives the congratulations, while the man remains the same timid copyist he always was. Recognition was granted to the surface.

    The profile is our overcoat. Like Akaky, we cut back on tea, light and sleep to sustain it. Like Akaky, we receive, for the first time, the gaze of others, and we mistake that gaze for existence. The difference is that Gogol’s overcoat at least kept the body warm. Ours demands the body’s warmth just to stay upright.

    On the way home from the party, in a dark, deserted square, the overcoat is stolen. Akaky goes to the police, without result, and turns to an “important person,” a senior official who receives him with shouting and humiliates him for daring to bother him.

    Akaky leaves there trembling, catches a fever, and dies a few days later. He didn’t die of cold. He died from the loss of the overcoat, because there was nothing left underneath it. The man had been emptied out to fill the object.

    That’s the answer to this essay’s central question. When a profile is hacked, canceled, banned, exposed to a pile-on, or simply forgotten by the algorithm, the person experiences that loss as a death, because that’s where they deposited their vital energy.

    And, like Akaky, they find no one to turn to. Today’s “important person” is the platform — faceless, addressless, responding only through an automated form. The governments that should protect us, as we’ve seen, are too busy managing their own profiles.

    Gogol doesn’t end the story with the death. Shortly after the funeral, a ghost begins wandering the bridges of St. Petersburg, snatching overcoats off the shoulders of passersby, until it finally reaches the “important person” himself.

    Giorgio Agamben — the Italian philosopher known for his work on biopolitics and contemporary “apparatuses” of power — observes, in his thinking on contemporary apparatuses, that they produce processes of desubjectification without giving rise to a new subject, except in a larval, spectral form. Akaky’s ghost is that figure.

    He is the subject who, stripped of himself, returns to strip others. It isn’t justice — it’s resentment. Each person who had their overcoat torn away goes out at night to tear away someone else’s. This is the digital mob that lynches, cancels and hounds, made up not of monsters, but of ghosts who were once humiliated themselves.

    Separated by nearly two centuries, both narratives arrive at the same point: a subject who dies from having deposited his life outside himself.

    A line often attributed to Dostoevsky holds that we all came out of Gogol’s Overcoat. Perhaps today it should be said that we all come out of the profile. This isn’t a call for some romantic escape from technology — that’s no longer within our reach.

    It’s a reminder of the warning Elisabeth ignored. You are one. There is no Sue without Elisabeth; there is no profile without the body stretched out on the bathroom floor. We need to get up off that floor, light the candl

    e, drink the tea, go to the date we canceled in front of the mirror.

    The overcoat exists to warm the body. When the body exists only to sustain the overcoat, death has already begun.

    This is a translated and edited version of the Portuguese-language column that first appeared on Instituto Humanitas Unisions (IHU), and has been republished with permission.

    https://www.ihu.unisinos.br/673404-como-sua-rede-social-esta-te-matando-artigo-de-alexandre-francisco

    Hope you loved reading this article. Global Catholic is powered by readers like you.

    We have no corporate owner or funding agencies. Our in-depth commentaries, features and conversations are not behind the paywall.

    We don’t carry advertisements as we want to offer a clutter-free reading experience.

    To sustain and grow Global Catholic, we need to raise US$250,000.

    Join the remarkable Global Catholic journey

    Share your comments

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    Pope Leo XIV welcomes Bob Dylan (third left) at the Vatican City alongside Fr. Antonio Spadaro (left). (Photo supplied)

    Bob Dylan and Pope Leo: two ‘Augustinians’

    Pope Leo XIV received Bob Dylan, an encounter rich with history, between a pope shaped by Augustine and the Bible, and a songwriter who has spoken Scripture for sixty years.
    Former US President Barack Obama (center) stands on stage with Democratic candidates Abdul El-Sayed (left) and Jocelyn Benson at a campaign rally in Detroit, Michigan. (Photo: Facebook/Democrats)

    An election and ‘humanating’

    Trump’s midterm defeat raises an uncomfortable question: did Americans repudiate Trumpism or just high fuel prices, and what would it mean to truly “humanate,” to live by Christ’s selfless love?
    A Christian man engaged in street ministry is seen holding a placard with a bible verse on God's love. (Photo: Pexels)

    Love: Most authentic force of evangelization

    The kerygma is God’s infinite love, and what truly attracts people to faith is not dogmatic orthodoxy but Christians who live that love toward the rejected and the suffering.
    Join the remarkable Global Catholic journey

    Join the remarkable Global Catholic journey

    Global Catholic is proud to be independent—editorially, politically, ideologically and financially.

    But independence comes at a cost. Without patron support, we depend entirely on readers and friends like you.

    To sustain and grow Global Catholic, we need to raise US$250,000.