In Australia, building more prisons is a policy of fear
Victoria’s spending on incarceration while cutting rehabilitation reflects fear and prejudice rather than sound policy, when strengthening relationships and community ties would better reduce crime and reoffending.
The Victorian 2025–26 state budget was marked by a contradiction. In an economy already overloaded with debt, Victoria committed US$727 million to preventing crime by incarcerating more people in detention centres and prisons.
The increase in funding came partly in response to laws restricting bail for people accused of crimes and also to the increased detention of children. Yet some community programs designed to reduce reoffending and help people rebuild their lives faced cuts or uncertain funding.
This makes it even more likely that people will return to prison, as around 40 per cent of those released in Victoria already do within two years.
Such contradictions are normally signs of bad policy and a shallow culture. They are also a reason why International Prisoners’ Justice Day this week is important.
The expansion of prisons despite their ineffectiveness reflects a fear that our society is out of control. That fear is fanned by press coverage of criminal acts and criticism of governments for failing to respond to them. It also reflects a deep-seated prejudice against prisoners and children who behave badly.
Such a volatile mixture of fear about an insecure society and prejudice against people who break the law leads government leaders to act in ways that contradict policies and decisions they had earlier advocated.
Victorian Government representatives who had earlier argued for raising the age of criminal responsibility to 14 now support adult punishment for adult crimes.
It is easy to dismiss such policy changes as the political expediency of ministers facing an election. In this case, however, they also reflect the responsibility of governments to reassure citizens that they can live safely and that the rule of law will be respected.
In a climate of anxiety and fear fanned by the media, governments will be pressured to offer temporary and illusory reassurance.
To change this cycle of fear and punitive lawmaking, both governments and the community must address the prejudices that fuel the fear that society is out of control.
❝
A society in which fewer people are prisoners can become more caring. It will celebrate the emptying of prisons, not their multiplication.
The prejudice we hold against prisoners
One of these demonizes people who break the law, particularly prisoners. We not only deplore their actions but also see them as different from and more dangerous than other people who are confined. The media fuel these fears through dramatic reporting of crime and by representing people accused of it as monsters.
These fears make it less intimidating to visit people in hospital or a nursing home than in prison. Our images of prisons, too, are of bluestone walls and cells or surgically cold places on the edge of the city.
We see prisoners as people who have been excluded from the places where others live and gather freely. The stigma attached to being a prisoner makes us keep our distance. It also makes us see prisoners as a homogeneous group rather than as persons like us.
They are defined not by their inner lives but by the crimes of which they have been accused. Most reports about prisons describe riots, stabbings or drugs. They may make us imagine prisoners as violent and powerful creatures who will wreak havoc if released.
Such prejudices prevent us from seeing prisoners as people like us and from asking how they came to be imprisoned.
In fact, they are more likely than most of us to have seen and experienced domestic violence as children, to have been exposed to drug abuse, to have lived in crowded accommodation, to have had learning difficulties at school, to lack social skills, to be affected by mental and physical ill health, to have been involved in the welfare and juvenile justice systems, to be unemployed as their parents were, and to have had little access to childhood health and welfare services. They have lived with disadvantage.
Why prison fails, and what could work
Confinement in prison does not help most prisoners. It weakens their already precarious connections with family and society. In addition to forced separation, the stigma of imprisonment and its erosion of self-esteem weaken people’s frail personal relationships and their connections with workplaces.
Although connections made in prison can help sustain some prisoners during their sentences, for others they may promote antisocial attitudes and skills.
When people are released from prison, any underlying mental illness, together with the prejudice against them, will make it more difficult for them to find accommodation, work and acceptance in the community. They will be more likely to reoffend and return to prison.
This is not to say that no one should be detained. Society has the right and duty to hold people responsible for actions that have injured others, to ensure that they have not gained from their wrongdoing, and to protect the community from vicious behaviour. This may require detaining people who directly threaten society.
The principal purpose of detention and other responses to crime, however, should be to encourage people to take responsibility for their actions and help them return to society and contribute to it. For most people, this will best be achieved by strengthening their relationships within the families and communities in which they live.
The money saved by keeping people out of prison can then be diverted to addressing the social circumstances that led to their imprisonment. It will also free public money for health and education and ensure that communities in which prisons are clustered do not depend financially on prison employment.
A society in which fewer people are prisoners can become more caring. It will celebrate the emptying of prisons, not their multiplication.
This column first appeared in Eureka Street and has been republished by Global Catholic with permission.
Hope you loved reading this article. Global Catholic is powered by readers like you.
We have no corporate owner or funding agencies. Our in-depth commentaries, features and conversations are not behind the paywall.
We don’t carry advertisements as we want to offer a clutter-free reading experience.
To sustain and grow Global Catholic, we need to raise US$250,000.
As Pope Leo XIV journeyed through Uruguay, Argentina and Peru, the international press read three messages: the renewal of faith, the defense of democracy, and solidarity with the poor.
The midterm rebuke to Trumpism offers the Church a chance to free itself from ideological captivity, from the partisan entanglements that distorted its moral and social teaching.
Pope Leo XIV received Bob Dylan, an encounter rich with history, between a pope shaped by Augustine and the Bible, and a songwriter who has spoken Scripture for sixty years.
Trump’s midterm defeat raises an uncomfortable question: did Americans repudiate Trumpism or just high fuel prices, and what would it mean to truly “humanate,” to live by Christ’s selfless love?
The kerygma is God’s infinite love, and what truly attracts people to faith is not dogmatic orthodoxy but Christians who live that love toward the rejected and the suffering.
As tech companies turn to religion for moral guidance, the real question is not whether machines can gain a conscience, but whether humanity has conscience enough to govern artificial intelligence.
In Australia, building more prisons is a policy of fear
Google Search
Subscribe to Newsletter
The Victorian 2025–26 state budget was marked by a contradiction. In an economy already overloaded with debt, Victoria committed US$727 million to preventing crime by incarcerating more people in detention centres and prisons.
The increase in funding came partly in response to laws restricting bail for people accused of crimes and also to the increased detention of children. Yet some community programs designed to reduce reoffending and help people rebuild their lives faced cuts or uncertain funding.
This makes it even more likely that people will return to prison, as around 40 per cent of those released in Victoria already do within two years.
Such contradictions are normally signs of bad policy and a shallow culture. They are also a reason why International Prisoners’ Justice Day this week is important.
The expansion of prisons despite their ineffectiveness reflects a fear that our society is out of control. That fear is fanned by press coverage of criminal acts and criticism of governments for failing to respond to them. It also reflects a deep-seated prejudice against prisoners and children who behave badly.
Such a volatile mixture of fear about an insecure society and prejudice against people who break the law leads government leaders to act in ways that contradict policies and decisions they had earlier advocated.
Victorian Government representatives who had earlier argued for raising the age of criminal responsibility to 14 now support adult punishment for adult crimes.
It is easy to dismiss such policy changes as the political expediency of ministers facing an election. In this case, however, they also reflect the responsibility of governments to reassure citizens that they can live safely and that the rule of law will be respected.
In a climate of anxiety and fear fanned by the media, governments will be pressured to offer temporary and illusory reassurance.
To change this cycle of fear and punitive lawmaking, both governments and the community must address the prejudices that fuel the fear that society is out of control.
❝
A society in which fewer people are prisoners can become more caring. It will celebrate the emptying of prisons, not their multiplication.
The prejudice we hold against prisoners
One of these demonizes people who break the law, particularly prisoners. We not only deplore their actions but also see them as different from and more dangerous than other people who are confined. The media fuel these fears through dramatic reporting of crime and by representing people accused of it as monsters.
These fears make it less intimidating to visit people in hospital or a nursing home than in prison. Our images of prisons, too, are of bluestone walls and cells or surgically cold places on the edge of the city.
We see prisoners as people who have been excluded from the places where others live and gather freely. The stigma attached to being a prisoner makes us keep our distance. It also makes us see prisoners as a homogeneous group rather than as persons like us.
They are defined not by their inner lives but by the crimes of which they have been accused. Most reports about prisons describe riots, stabbings or drugs. They may make us imagine prisoners as violent and powerful creatures who will wreak havoc if released.
Such prejudices prevent us from seeing prisoners as people like us and from asking how they came to be imprisoned.
In fact, they are more likely than most of us to have seen and experienced domestic violence as children, to have been exposed to drug abuse, to have lived in crowded accommodation, to have had learning difficulties at school, to lack social skills, to be affected by mental and physical ill health, to have been involved in the welfare and juvenile justice systems, to be unemployed as their parents were, and to have had little access to childhood health and welfare services. They have lived with disadvantage.
Why prison fails, and what could work
Confinement in prison does not help most prisoners. It weakens their already precarious connections with family and society. In addition to forced separation, the stigma of imprisonment and its erosion of self-esteem weaken people’s frail personal relationships and their connections with workplaces.
Although connections made in prison can help sustain some prisoners during their sentences, for others they may promote antisocial attitudes and skills.
When people are released from prison, any underlying mental illness, together with the prejudice against them, will make it more difficult for them to find accommodation, work and acceptance in the community. They will be more likely to reoffend and return to prison.
This is not to say that no one should be detained. Society has the right and duty to hold people responsible for actions that have injured others, to ensure that they have not gained from their wrongdoing, and to protect the community from vicious behaviour. This may require detaining people who directly threaten society.
The principal purpose of detention and other responses to crime, however, should be to encourage people to take responsibility for their actions and help them return to society and contribute to it. For most people, this will best be achieved by strengthening their relationships within the families and communities in which they live.
The money saved by keeping people out of prison can then be diverted to addressing the social circumstances that led to their imprisonment. It will also free public money for health and education and ensure that communities in which prisons are clustered do not depend financially on prison employment.
A society in which fewer people are prisoners can become more caring. It will celebrate the emptying of prisons, not their multiplication.
This column first appeared in Eureka Street and has been republished by Global Catholic with permission.
Hope you loved reading this article. Global Catholic is powered by readers like you.
We have no corporate owner or funding agencies. Our in-depth commentaries, features and conversations are not behind the paywall.
We don’t carry advertisements as we want to offer a clutter-free reading experience.
To sustain and grow Global Catholic, we need to raise US$250,000.
Join the remarkable Global Catholic journey
VATICAN DIARY
Leo in Latin America, as the international press saw him
SIGNS OF THE TIMES
US midterms: A liberating invitation for the US Church
WAYPOINTS
Bob Dylan and Pope Leo: two ‘Augustinians’
GRIMMGRAM
An election and ‘humanating’
LIGHTS AND SHADOWS
Love: Most authentic force of evangelization
MORALITY MATTERS
Can Artificial Intelligence have a conscience?
Latest
Stewardship and the dignity of every person
Cambridge’s 2026 word of the year is “human,” and so is Pope Leo’s encyclical
How Patriarch Kirill fused his office with his own personal power
Australia’s wave of job cuts forgets the human cost of work
AI might be eating what remains of your Catholic soul
Venite ad me: Why Vatican’s effort on faith transmission is moving at snail’s pace
Trending
Why the German Church still wrestles with its liturgical translations from Latin
Catholic Social Teaching and the non-person
Neither flight, nor flag: Benedict, Dominic and the Council
Council of Crete at 10: The unfinished work of Christian unity
AI might be eating what remains of your Catholic soul
Poverty: An indictment of society’s ethical crisis
Leo in Latin America, as the international press saw him
Stewardship and the dignity of every person
How Patriarch Kirill fused his office with his own personal power
The age of deference is over, even in the Church