Priestly amnesia: forgetting Christ, the root of vocation

Amid today’s many crises, the crisis of priestly identity is rooted in an anthropological amnesia, as formation modeled on “total institutions” and a resistance to engaging post-Christian culture leave priests disconnected from Christ, the true foundation of their vocation.
A priest walks along the river Tiber in Rome, Italy. (Photo: Unsplash/Alberico Bartoccini)
A priest walks along the river Tiber in Rome, Italy. (Photo: Unsplash/Alberico Bartoccini)

Subscribe to Newsletter

    The world has its own paradigms of identity. We are in an age in which existence determines being, rather than Being determining existence. It is a post-theistic era.

    Behind this observation lie centuries of the history of Christian thought.

    Catholic theology—at least as we can understand it through the ‘anthropological turn’ established by the Second Vatican Council, even from its Christocentric foundation (Gaudium et Spes, 22)—could not help but bring to its anthropological compass that consequence of the emphasis placed on the subject and on the conditions for a mature and relational autonomy.

    Even today, we struggle to engage in dialogue with contemporary subjectivities—from within our own internal structures, and even more so in our hoped-for dialogue with post-Christian culture.

    The monolithic and unilateral conditions drawn by the values of Western Christendom no longer exist, however much some insist, naively and self-deceptively, on trying to reclaim them—perhaps with the fragile hope that through them we would be “pure and simple” Catholics, as if we could be such without what lies at the root of the “essence of Christianity,” which is always Jesus Christ, the same yesterday, today, and forever (Heb 13:8).

    We have struggled to sustain a dialogue with hypermodern phenomena. We still want to impose rather than allow ourselves to be questioned. This is why the synodal approach launched by Pope Francis still meets resistance to its development.

    Recognizing the many ways of being and acting in the world and in history will always present difficulties for synthesis and new beginnings.

    The crisis of priestly identity

    In this landscape of so many crises—ecological, migratory, economic, crises of values, of identity, of faith, and so on—and their anthropological consequences, we see that the ways of living ordained ministry also fall into existential confusion, leading us to slip either into an immanentist progressivism devoid of spirit, or into a disembodied traditionalism, historically alienated.

    In both, we can recognize what Pope Francis denounced when he referred to the new forms of Pelagianism and Gnosticism as enemies of holiness in today’s world (Gaudete et Exsultate, ch. II).

    We might consider the drama surrounding priestly identity in our times through these two ways of living out these heresies—so ancient and yet ever new—since they undermine the primacy of God’s grace in the dynamic of vocation.

    This has led us into a coexistence with “spiritual worldliness,” which is more than just a distorted style of exercising power in the Church, which is clericalism.

    The first is an anthropological problem, and consequently a theological one. In the second, we see the phenomena of a priestly existence lacking testimony and deep convictions about who we are and how we are called to be priests in postmodern, post-Christian culture.

    There is a self-centered immaturity that closes us off in bubbles insensitive to what is presented by the new “systemic order” (N. Luhmann), which, as much as in the past, demands from each of us the marks of holiness, with its “mysticism of open eyes” (J. Baptist Metz).

    One of the issues running through and fueling this denial of engagement with reality—and consequently, the graduated forms of amnesia regarding who we are, regarding our founding principle as priests, which is Jesus Christ—is our continued denial of our relational subjectivity: that is, ourselves and the wholly Other, who is Our Lord Jesus Christ, the One by whom we are called to be addressed.

    We must also include other human beings, with their unique and universal dignity.

    Formation as a ‘total institution’

    Our formation still places greater value on what Erving Goffman calls “total institutions” (Asylums, pp. 16–22).

    One can infer from this reading that many arrive at the exercise of ministry without a deep identification with the person of Jesus Christ—not simply from a dogmatic standpoint, but above all existentially, with an awareness of being a disciple and missionary of the Lord.

    ❝

    As long as we are not grounded in a profound Christian mysticism, rooted in the Joy of the Gospel, we will continue to be amnesiac in our priestly identity

    His paradigm is not theological but sociological. Following his idea of what total institutions are—and here formation houses fit in—these are still not mature enough, either in their structures or in their human capital, to recognize the dignity and freedom of all those who feel called to ordained ministry in the Church and for the world.

    Taking into account contemporary anthropology with its various social manifestations, “in modern society the individual tends to sleep, play, and work in different places, with different co-participants, under different authorities, and without an overarching rational plan. The central feature of total institutions can be described as the breakdown of the barriers that ordinarily separate these three spheres: the same location and authority; the same people and set of activities; and a single rational plan” (ibid., pp. 17–18).

    Contrary to what we continue to assume, mass disciplinary formation tends to shape—churchmen bound to the institution—rather than form—Christian missionary disciples.

    In this sense, whoever is there may not truly be there; whoever speaks may not be conscious of what is said. That is why, before and after, in ministerial life, careers and bureaucracy become more important than evangelical witness.

    I reiterate that the proposal is one of integration, not the cancellation of one dimension in favor of another. Even so, I would reposition the second in relation to the first.

    Structures, bodies, and committees, along with their representatives, cannot continue to deny the centrality of the person and of the Christian being of all those involved in the process. We continue to make the same mistakes in reading the signs of new times and their challenges.

    The amnesia experienced by many priests today—and here lies the problem of the identity crisis—has to do, above all, with various anthropological, social, and planetary factors.

    We are, as much as other human beings, a microcosm within an ecology that is, indeed, integral and to which we all need to integrate ourselves. We still want to form new priests and cultivate our ongoing formation without attention to what this post-organic humanity is living through.

    Either we engage in dialogue with the new subjectivities, or we will keep seeking to close ourselves off and offer answers to questions no one is asking anymore. This amnesia, before being priestly, is anthropological. Here the psalmist’s question applies: “What is man, Lord, that you care for him so?” (Ps 8:4).

    Benedict XVI’s vision for formation

    Finally, I draw on Pope Benedict XVI’s address to seminarians in Cologne, during World Youth Day XX.

    In this exhortation, there are many teachings about the mission of seminaries in our times and, I would add, of our presbyteries, which need to keep in mind the urgency of a mentality of ongoing formation (“Ongoing formation: a mindset”).

    Benedict stated that “the seminary is a time of formation and discernment.” This always converges toward the unity of the person.

    Its deepest goal, the pontiff affirmed, “is to come to know intimately that God who in Jesus Christ has shown us his face.” He continued, saying that “all this must be joined with the questions raised by our reason, and therefore with the context of human life today.

    This study can sometimes seem difficult, but it constitutes an irreplaceable part of our encounter with Christ and of our call to proclaim Him.

    Everything works together to develop a coherent and balanced personality, capable of properly taking on and then responsibly carrying out the priestly mission.

    The role of formators is decisive: “the quality of the presbyterate in a particular Church depends in large part on the seminary, and therefore on the quality of those responsible for formation.'” (Pope Benedict XVI’s address during his Apostolic Journey to Cologne, Germany on World Youth Day XX 2005).

    Finally, Benedict emphasizes that “the seminary is a time of preparation for mission”

    There is an urgent need for rediscovery, with new impressions and hermeneutical capacities; without fear of the new and courageously engaged with the geographic and existential concreteness of the contemporary human being.

    As long as we are not grounded in a profound Christian mysticism, rooted in the Joy of the Gospel, we will continue to be amnesiac in our priestly identity, because before that, we are confused about our human and Christian vocation. So be it!

    This is a translated, edited, and summarized version of the column that first appeared on Instituto Humanitas Unisinos (IUH), and has been republished with permission by Global Catholic.

    Hope you loved reading this article. Global Catholic is powered by readers like you.

    We have no corporate owner or funding agencies. Our in-depth commentaries, features and conversations are not behind the paywall.

    We don’t carry advertisements as we want to offer a clutter-free reading experience.

    To sustain and grow Global Catholic, we need to raise US$250,000.

    Join the remarkable Global Catholic journey

    Share your comments

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    Pope Leo XIV welcomes Bob Dylan (third left) at the Vatican City alongside Fr. Antonio Spadaro (left). (Photo supplied)

    Bob Dylan and Pope Leo: two ‘Augustinians’

    Pope Leo XIV received Bob Dylan, an encounter rich with history, between a pope shaped by Augustine and the Bible, and a songwriter who has spoken Scripture for sixty years.
    Former US President Barack Obama (center) stands on stage with Democratic candidates Abdul El-Sayed (left) and Jocelyn Benson at a campaign rally in Detroit, Michigan. (Photo: Facebook/Democrats)

    An election and ‘humanating’

    Trump’s midterm defeat raises an uncomfortable question: did Americans repudiate Trumpism or just high fuel prices, and what would it mean to truly “humanate,” to live by Christ’s selfless love?
    A Christian man engaged in street ministry is seen holding a placard with a bible verse on God's love. (Photo: Pexels)

    Love: Most authentic force of evangelization

    The kerygma is God’s infinite love, and what truly attracts people to faith is not dogmatic orthodoxy but Christians who live that love toward the rejected and the suffering.
    Join the remarkable Global Catholic journey

    Join the remarkable Global Catholic journey

    Global Catholic is proud to be independent—editorially, politically, ideologically and financially.

    But independence comes at a cost. Without patron support, we depend entirely on readers and friends like you.

    To sustain and grow Global Catholic, we need to raise US$250,000.