What does Catholic teaching say about the triumph of capitalism?
Catholic social teaching accepts capitalism’s strengths while rejecting unrestrained markets, and demands that laws, taxation, and ethical safeguards ensure that wealth and technology benefit society.
Hardly any small book published in the last 50 years has been more important for business ethics than The Passions and the Interests by Albert O. Hirschman.
This book was originally published in 1980 under the title The Passions and the Interests: Political Arguments for Capitalism Before Its Triumph.
The German-born and deeply humane economist, who worked in the United States, sharply demonstrated the advantages of capitalism before its triumph.
In just 120 pages, he emphasizes two points.
Since the Italian Renaissance and the Franciscan poverty movement of the 13th and 14th centuries, what Franciscan preachers called capitalism — named after the capites, or “heads,” of the countless sheep owned by wealthy merchants in the 14th century, whose wool production generated enormous fortunes — has sought to tame human passions for money and property by channeling them.
Greed is worse than sexual sins
This is achieved through fair competition, redistribution, guarantees of private property, and, of course, laws that apply equally to all market participants.
Behind this development lies an insight already recognized by the early Franciscans: people desire money more than sex.
The commandment “You shall not steal” is more important than “You shall not commit adultery” and everything associated with sexual temptation. Lust is less serious and less consequential than greed.
Bertolt Brecht might have said: “Food comes first, then morality.”
The early Franciscans, therefore, shifted their preaching away from sexual morality toward material concerns—profit-seeking and greed.
At the same time, they avoided futile calls for people to simply become less greedy. Instead, they sought to restrain what could not be eliminated.
Human beings, after all, are not only lustful but even more deeply driven by greed. As for the lust for power, that is another topic entirely and would require a discussion of the invention of parliamentary democracy.
The permanency of wealth inequality
Since greed cannot be eliminated before the dawn of Judgment Day—except through the horrific mass deaths caused by communism—it must instead be restrained, channeled, and reduced.
The inequality of wealth and property remains a permanent scandal until the arrival of God’s “propertyless” eternity. Yet it is moderated and softened through the rule of law and the welfare state.
This is also why Christianity gradually accepted something initially unfamiliar to it: charging interest. The English word “interest” reflects the interest in profitable financial growth under public law.
What the early Franciscans did not know, however—and what even the legendary Adam Smith failed to foresee with his inadequate notion of the invisible hand of the market—is that nation-states and tariff barriers can enforce moral limits on economic activity far more effectively than a global economy can, especially when countries such as China and India operate under very different moral frameworks.
How many billionaires, perhaps even trillionaires, already exist in India and China?
And yet we are upset about Elon Musk and his space company, SpaceX, which went public on Nasdaq on June 12, 2026, with a record valuation of 1.75 trillion US dollars?
There are reasons for this concern, as modern stock exchanges are intended to provide public valuations and encourage thoughtful investment. SpaceX has reduced the cost of access to space by 95 percent and now launches the majority of payloads placed into orbit, providing broad public benefits.
From unrestrained to inclusive capitalism
So, all’s well that ends well? Are money and profit, therefore, good?
Pope Leo XIV rightly warns in his new encyclical Magnifica Humanitas, as did Albert O. Hirschman, against unrestrained capitalism.
What is needed is not so much a limitation on the pursuit of profit itself as transparent laws that limit stock market gains through taxation. Such measures, however—as noted above—are much more difficult to implement globally than within nation-states.
Complaining about this is a waste of time.
It is better for groups of states and trade unions to move forward and introduce such taxes. A stock market regulated through the social market economy is preferable to one operating in an unrestricted capitalist system.
Outrage and lamentation accomplish little.
What is needed is the simple insight that the common good takes precedence over private gain.
Artificial intelligence in the hands of a few trillionaires appears to promote limitless private profit on an obscene scale. This was not fundamentally different from the era of the American steel barons after the Civil War of 1865, although it was less obvious and less vulgar.
In every field, AI must be supervised and limited through laws for the benefit of all.
This requires discussion and negotiation in democratic parliaments, at the national level, and internationally.
Only then can an inclusive capitalism emerge—one with an ethic that serves everyone, including weaker market participants.
Elon Musk’s stock market windfall merely opens another chapter in the great book of capitalism, which is irritating yet unavoidable on the path toward the gradual humanization of humanity.
For, unfortunately, no better economic system has yet been found.
And capitalism will not truly have triumphed until every person shares adequately in life’s material blessings. That will probably happen shortly before the Last Judgment, in anticipation of the eternal blessings of life.
Blessed are we if we do not then stand before the task of improving the world with empty hands—or, put differently, if some do not stand there with full pockets and empty heads. For then the leap into the riches of divine love may prove difficult, a leap for which stock market wealth offers little preparation.
To remind people of this is the task of the Church and of Catholic social teaching. And at present, it is no small part of the mission of Pope Leo XIV.
This is a translated and edited version of the interview that first appeared on DOMRADIO.DE and has been republished with permission by Global Catholic.
Hope you loved reading this article. Global Catholic is powered by readers like you.
We have no corporate owner or funding agencies. Our in-depth commentaries, features and conversations are not behind the paywall.
We don’t carry advertisements as we want to offer a clutter-free reading experience.
To sustain and grow Global Catholic, we need to raise US$250,000.
As Pope Leo XIV journeyed through Uruguay, Argentina and Peru, the international press read three messages: the renewal of faith, the defense of democracy, and solidarity with the poor.
The midterm rebuke to Trumpism offers the Church a chance to free itself from ideological captivity, from the partisan entanglements that distorted its moral and social teaching.
Pope Leo XIV received Bob Dylan, an encounter rich with history, between a pope shaped by Augustine and the Bible, and a songwriter who has spoken Scripture for sixty years.
Trump’s midterm defeat raises an uncomfortable question: did Americans repudiate Trumpism or just high fuel prices, and what would it mean to truly “humanate,” to live by Christ’s selfless love?
The kerygma is God’s infinite love, and what truly attracts people to faith is not dogmatic orthodoxy but Christians who live that love toward the rejected and the suffering.
As tech companies turn to religion for moral guidance, the real question is not whether machines can gain a conscience, but whether humanity has conscience enough to govern artificial intelligence.
What does Catholic teaching say about the triumph of capitalism?
Google Search
Subscribe to Newsletter
Hardly any small book published in the last 50 years has been more important for business ethics than The Passions and the Interests by Albert O. Hirschman.
This book was originally published in 1980 under the title The Passions and the Interests: Political Arguments for Capitalism Before Its Triumph.
The German-born and deeply humane economist, who worked in the United States, sharply demonstrated the advantages of capitalism before its triumph.
In just 120 pages, he emphasizes two points.
Since the Italian Renaissance and the Franciscan poverty movement of the 13th and 14th centuries, what Franciscan preachers called capitalism — named after the capites, or “heads,” of the countless sheep owned by wealthy merchants in the 14th century, whose wool production generated enormous fortunes — has sought to tame human passions for money and property by channeling them.
Greed is worse than sexual sins
This is achieved through fair competition, redistribution, guarantees of private property, and, of course, laws that apply equally to all market participants.
Behind this development lies an insight already recognized by the early Franciscans: people desire money more than sex.
The commandment “You shall not steal” is more important than “You shall not commit adultery” and everything associated with sexual temptation. Lust is less serious and less consequential than greed.
Bertolt Brecht might have said: “Food comes first, then morality.”
The early Franciscans, therefore, shifted their preaching away from sexual morality toward material concerns—profit-seeking and greed.
At the same time, they avoided futile calls for people to simply become less greedy. Instead, they sought to restrain what could not be eliminated.
Human beings, after all, are not only lustful but even more deeply driven by greed. As for the lust for power, that is another topic entirely and would require a discussion of the invention of parliamentary democracy.
The permanency of wealth inequality
Since greed cannot be eliminated before the dawn of Judgment Day—except through the horrific mass deaths caused by communism—it must instead be restrained, channeled, and reduced.
The inequality of wealth and property remains a permanent scandal until the arrival of God’s “propertyless” eternity. Yet it is moderated and softened through the rule of law and the welfare state.
This is also why Christianity gradually accepted something initially unfamiliar to it: charging interest. The English word “interest” reflects the interest in profitable financial growth under public law.
What the early Franciscans did not know, however—and what even the legendary Adam Smith failed to foresee with his inadequate notion of the invisible hand of the market—is that nation-states and tariff barriers can enforce moral limits on economic activity far more effectively than a global economy can, especially when countries such as China and India operate under very different moral frameworks.
How many billionaires, perhaps even trillionaires, already exist in India and China?
And yet we are upset about Elon Musk and his space company, SpaceX, which went public on Nasdaq on June 12, 2026, with a record valuation of 1.75 trillion US dollars?
There are reasons for this concern, as modern stock exchanges are intended to provide public valuations and encourage thoughtful investment. SpaceX has reduced the cost of access to space by 95 percent and now launches the majority of payloads placed into orbit, providing broad public benefits.
From unrestrained to inclusive capitalism
So, all’s well that ends well? Are money and profit, therefore, good?
Pope Leo XIV rightly warns in his new encyclical Magnifica Humanitas, as did Albert O. Hirschman, against unrestrained capitalism.
What is needed is not so much a limitation on the pursuit of profit itself as transparent laws that limit stock market gains through taxation. Such measures, however—as noted above—are much more difficult to implement globally than within nation-states.
Complaining about this is a waste of time.
It is better for groups of states and trade unions to move forward and introduce such taxes. A stock market regulated through the social market economy is preferable to one operating in an unrestricted capitalist system.
Outrage and lamentation accomplish little.
What is needed is the simple insight that the common good takes precedence over private gain.
Artificial intelligence in the hands of a few trillionaires appears to promote limitless private profit on an obscene scale. This was not fundamentally different from the era of the American steel barons after the Civil War of 1865, although it was less obvious and less vulgar.
In every field, AI must be supervised and limited through laws for the benefit of all.
This requires discussion and negotiation in democratic parliaments, at the national level, and internationally.
Only then can an inclusive capitalism emerge—one with an ethic that serves everyone, including weaker market participants.
Elon Musk’s stock market windfall merely opens another chapter in the great book of capitalism, which is irritating yet unavoidable on the path toward the gradual humanization of humanity.
For, unfortunately, no better economic system has yet been found.
And capitalism will not truly have triumphed until every person shares adequately in life’s material blessings. That will probably happen shortly before the Last Judgment, in anticipation of the eternal blessings of life.
Blessed are we if we do not then stand before the task of improving the world with empty hands—or, put differently, if some do not stand there with full pockets and empty heads. For then the leap into the riches of divine love may prove difficult, a leap for which stock market wealth offers little preparation.
To remind people of this is the task of the Church and of Catholic social teaching. And at present, it is no small part of the mission of Pope Leo XIV.
This is a translated and edited version of the interview that first appeared on DOMRADIO.DE and has been republished with permission by Global Catholic.
Hope you loved reading this article. Global Catholic is powered by readers like you.
We have no corporate owner or funding agencies. Our in-depth commentaries, features and conversations are not behind the paywall.
We don’t carry advertisements as we want to offer a clutter-free reading experience.
To sustain and grow Global Catholic, we need to raise US$250,000.
Join the remarkable Global Catholic journey
VATICAN DIARY
Leo in Latin America, as the international press saw him
SIGNS OF THE TIMES
US midterms: A liberating invitation for the US Church
WAYPOINTS
Bob Dylan and Pope Leo: two ‘Augustinians’
GRIMMGRAM
An election and ‘humanating’
LIGHTS AND SHADOWS
Love: Most authentic force of evangelization
MORALITY MATTERS
Can Artificial Intelligence have a conscience?
Latest
Stewardship and the dignity of every person
Cambridge’s 2026 word of the year is “human,” and so is Pope Leo’s encyclical
How Patriarch Kirill fused his office with his own personal power
Australia’s wave of job cuts forgets the human cost of work
AI might be eating what remains of your Catholic soul
Venite ad me: Why Vatican’s effort on faith transmission is moving at snail’s pace
Trending
Why the German Church still wrestles with its liturgical translations from Latin
Catholic Social Teaching and the non-person
Neither flight, nor flag: Benedict, Dominic and the Council
Council of Crete at 10: The unfinished work of Christian unity
AI might be eating what remains of your Catholic soul
Poverty: An indictment of society’s ethical crisis
Leo in Latin America, as the international press saw him
Stewardship and the dignity of every person
How Patriarch Kirill fused his office with his own personal power
The age of deference is over, even in the Church