Irish President Connolly’s gift of St. Brendan’s voyage story to Donald Trump offers a subtle diplomatic critique, contrasting spiritual exploration with territorial conquest.
It is the custom, when heads of state visit one another, to exchange gifts with due ceremony in honor of the occasion.
Such gifts usually carry cultural, diplomatic, or historic significance.
What, then, did Mr Trump make of being handed a copy of the Navigatio Sancti Brendani Abbatis by President Catherine Connolly during his stopover in Dublin, on the way to his golf course in County Clare?
A legendary Irish journey
What is the Navigatio anyway? It is one of Ireland’s best-loved stories about one of her best-loved saints: how St Brendan set off with a company of monks in search of the Promised Land of the Saints, and the extraordinary adventures they met along the way.
On one occasion, they land on an island, light a fire to cook, and find the land swimming away beneath them—it is a whale.
Beyond the fantastical adventure, the story is a cleverly constructed framework of the monastic cycle of prayer, observed wherever the sea takes them.
Pointed diplomatic presents
Diplomatic gifts often carry an underlying point.
Consider the ship’s bell King Charles gave Mr Trump on his visit to the United States: the significance was lost on no one except the recipient.
Would he find more in the Navigatio? Let us look a little closer.
Searching for promised lands
The monks were searching for a Promised Land.
Mr Trump’s presidency has been one long search for lands he seems to believe were promised to him: Venezuela, Greenland, Canada.
Yet Brendan’s aim was not annexation, conquest, or invasion—it was to find the presence of God and enter it in peace.
Prayer was the very essence of the voyage.
The monks kept a daily, monthly, and yearly rhythm of devotion, observed the times and seasons, and tried to keep God’s commandments faithfully. A monk who failed was duly punished.
Sent home without deeds
And here is the detail Mr Trump may like least: after seven years of wandering, Brendan’s monks finally reach the Promised Land.
They are allowed forty days to explore it—and are then sent home, because it is not theirs to keep. It will be revealed to their successors in God’s good time.
A seven-year journey to the Promised Land, forty days to admire it, and sent home without a deed: for a guest in perpetual search of lands to acquire, President Connolly could hardly have chosen a finer gift.
This column first appeared on Flashes of Insight and has been republished with permission by Global Catholic.
Hope you loved reading this article. Global Catholic is powered by readers like you.
We have no corporate owner or funding agencies. Our in-depth commentaries, features and conversations are not behind the paywall.
We don’t carry advertisements as we want to offer a clutter-free reading experience.
To sustain and grow Global Catholic, we need to raise US$250,000.
Even as pope, Leo XIV submitted his vote-by-mail ballot for the US midterms, a gesture the Vatican presented as fidelity to the citizen’s duty of participation.
Venite ad Me is notable for what it omits, the role of universities and academic theology, revealing a mutual alienation between the Church and theology.
Debates over ancient evidence on women’s ordination miss the point: Jesus affirmed women’s full discipleship, and the real question is what the Church must create for this century, not past ones.
The ‘Vatican Note A Journey of Hope’ reaffirms Nostra Aetate’s call for authentic interreligious dialogue to build peace and resist political exploitation without diluting Catholic identity.
The Indian Church already depends enormously on women’s work, and the real task is not clericalizing them but moving from “help” to genuine co-responsibility, receiving their gifts more fully.
The pointed message in Ireland’s gift for Trump
Google Search
Subscribe to Newsletter
It is the custom, when heads of state visit one another, to exchange gifts with due ceremony in honor of the occasion.
Such gifts usually carry cultural, diplomatic, or historic significance.
What, then, did Mr Trump make of being handed a copy of the Navigatio Sancti Brendani Abbatis by President Catherine Connolly during his stopover in Dublin, on the way to his golf course in County Clare?
A legendary Irish journey
What is the Navigatio anyway? It is one of Ireland’s best-loved stories about one of her best-loved saints: how St Brendan set off with a company of monks in search of the Promised Land of the Saints, and the extraordinary adventures they met along the way.
On one occasion, they land on an island, light a fire to cook, and find the land swimming away beneath them—it is a whale.
Beyond the fantastical adventure, the story is a cleverly constructed framework of the monastic cycle of prayer, observed wherever the sea takes them.
Pointed diplomatic presents
Diplomatic gifts often carry an underlying point.
Consider the ship’s bell King Charles gave Mr Trump on his visit to the United States: the significance was lost on no one except the recipient.
Would he find more in the Navigatio? Let us look a little closer.
Searching for promised lands
The monks were searching for a Promised Land.
Mr Trump’s presidency has been one long search for lands he seems to believe were promised to him: Venezuela, Greenland, Canada.
Yet Brendan’s aim was not annexation, conquest, or invasion—it was to find the presence of God and enter it in peace.
Prayer was the very essence of the voyage.
The monks kept a daily, monthly, and yearly rhythm of devotion, observed the times and seasons, and tried to keep God’s commandments faithfully. A monk who failed was duly punished.
Sent home without deeds
And here is the detail Mr Trump may like least: after seven years of wandering, Brendan’s monks finally reach the Promised Land.
They are allowed forty days to explore it—and are then sent home, because it is not theirs to keep. It will be revealed to their successors in God’s good time.
A seven-year journey to the Promised Land, forty days to admire it, and sent home without a deed: for a guest in perpetual search of lands to acquire, President Connolly could hardly have chosen a finer gift.
This column first appeared on Flashes of Insight and has been republished with permission by Global Catholic.
Hope you loved reading this article. Global Catholic is powered by readers like you.
We have no corporate owner or funding agencies. Our in-depth commentaries, features and conversations are not behind the paywall.
We don’t carry advertisements as we want to offer a clutter-free reading experience.
To sustain and grow Global Catholic, we need to raise US$250,000.
Join the remarkable Global Catholic journey
VATICAN DIARY
Pope Leo and the American Midterms
SIGNS OF THE TIMES
Venite ad Me: Catholic universities and the crisis of theologizing
WAYPOINTS
Pope Leo and the world’s great museums
GRIMMGRAM
First things first
LIGHTS AND SHADOWS
Nostra Aetate, a journey of hope: Embracing the challenge of otherness
MORALITY MATTERS
The Indian Church runs on women. How can it more fully receive their gifts?
Latest
A towel, not a throne: the Church Jesus envisioned
The sacraments are not symbols, but encounters with God
Thirty years on, why Cardinal Bernardin still matters
Meet the German Protestant sisters caring for leprosy outcasts in Pakistan
Oviedo Cathedral’s ban on Netflix’s ‘La Regenta’ revives a 150-year censorship saga
Pope Leo’s call for transparency and evidence destruction
Trending
Venite ad Me: Catholic universities and the crisis of theologizing
‘What do you think sex is for?’
When Leo revisits Vatican Council’s rare superlative
Two popes, one heart: Magnifica Humanitas and the second year of Dilexit Nos
A doctorate and a vocation: What the Orientale gave Patriarch Bartholomew
Pope Leo’s call for transparency and evidence destruction
Pope Leo and the American Midterms
Venite ad Me: a realistic reckoning with the collapse of faith
Pope Leo’s visit to Cameroon: What has changed?
The conscious use of artificial intelligence